SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

Haha, honestly, I am with you on that. I doubt the majority will agree but I wont be competing in a 730 am trivia so I would be for lynching before them. Yes, I am a selfish bastard.

I'm not doing it either. Honestly though, it's because I'm town aligned. If I were mafia, I'd probably wake up for it knowing we had limited numbers.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by Rob S

I'm not doing it either. Honestly though, it's because I'm town aligned. If I were mafia, I'd probably wake up for it knowing we had limited numbers.

Yup. They will go hard for it. They have to win that **** to stand a chance.

[Rob S]

vote: Brody

Not totally sure, but passing on this lynch would be dumb imo. The evidence is about as good as you can get day 2. Plus, I really think there is a decent chance mafia wins trivia considering it is at 7:30 am.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by CJSchneider

Any mistakes I make are contributed to the fact that I refuse to edit, even ninja edit, a mistake once I post a remark. They are not meant to be characteristic of my current role or character assignment.

Spoken in quite a legalistic manner. I just wanted to make sure we weren't missing anything.

[Gay Ork Wang]

I might have a chance at that trivia thing!

[Brodeur]

I don't have the time to fight this tomorrow because I work from 7 AM to noon, so if you're going to stupidly lynch me, go ahead. I'll stick with Caddy because I'm pretty sure he's evil.

[RufusMcDaniel]

I am guaranteeing a trivia victory tomorrow morning.

[Rob S]

The more I think about it, the more I think it will be a boneheaded move to let this go to trivia. Brody will probably be the lynch regardless and giving the mafia a chance to power up is stupid. The power up is far more useful for the mafia right now because we don't have a great read on who is suspect while they, obviously, know who is good.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by Rob S

The more I think about it, the more I think it will be a boneheaded move to let this go to trivia. Brody will probably be the lynch regardless and giving the mafia a chance to power up is stupid. The power up is far more useful for the mafia right now because we don't have a great read on who is suspect while they, obviously, know who is good.

Exactly my thought. In their hands they do some serious damage, in ours we might damage ourselves. Pretty clear decision, lynch Brodeur tonight.

[OSUGiants17]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

Look at what CJ has added to the thread. Some soft defences, not much else. He just does not strike me as good CJ.

Fenikz I have a feeling about. Seems like he is playing a Fenikz mafia style game.

I backed my **** up, do you have anything to contribute or will you just continue to be useless, be angry, contribute nothing because you say its only day two, and tell us you can help the town later which I bet will be some xshot mularky.

Why must it be mularky that I can only use my night action once? Also, so far my only suspicion is Brody due to the reason's already stated, but because I wasn't here all day that will just get me accused of adding nothing and hopping on a lynch train even though I'm not.

[CashmoneyDrew]

I'm setting my alarm for 6:25 so I can solve the trivia, then go back to sleep for two more hours. Don't even bother, mafia.

[Brodeur]

Drew isn't voting for me, that should be a hint to you idiots that I'm not evil.

[Rob S]

I really, really encourage everyone to just kill brody tonight before the deadline for trivia. What use is the power up to a town member really? It will likely be a kill/roleblock/jailkeep/etc. and we don't know what's what right now. What we do know that brody roleblocked me last night.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

Drew isn't voting for me, that should be a hint to you idiots that I'm not evil.

You have to be up by 7 AM.....get to sleep, Brody.

[Brodeur]

Originally Posted by Rob S

You have to be up by 7 AM.....get to sleep, Brody.

I work at 7 AM, so unless you think I wake up at work which is 30 minutes away plus parking and a 19 floor elevator ride...

[Bulldogs]

I'm taking note of those defending Brody in case he turns up evil. Lot's of subtle defenses.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

I work at 7 AM, so unless you think I wake up at work which is 30 minutes away plus parking and a 19 floor elevator ride...

Well, damn....you're even further behind sleep wise than I thought.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by Rob S

Jailkeeping/roleblocking me was whatever. I'm not bitter. Night one is a crapshoot. Still though, I don't see an option better than Brody right now. We have a 50/50 shot.

Another option (if we believe TH) is to kill someone else and have TH target Brody every night so if he doesn't use the RB/JK on TH, he will die.

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

Again, in all of the games I've played or modded, I can't recall a single instance of forcing a guy to use his powers in a certain way actually working out.

I don't see how this applies here. If we go by Rob's plan we will know instantly if Brodeur is lying and we won't even have to lynch him because he'll be dead.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by Bulldogs

I'm taking note of those defending Brody in case he turns up evil. Lot's of subtle defenses.

It may sound crazy but I think it will be more telling of those defending him if he came up good. Either way, those offering soft defences should be looked at.

[Brodeur]

Originally Posted by Bulldogs

I'm taking note of those defending Brody in case he turns up evil. Lot's of subtle defenses.

Hopefully you're willing to take the hit when you realize that I'm a good guy, but too bad you and Gonzo will pull the same **** you always pull. Baines, always playing the same stupid way.

[Rob S]

This just strikes me as pretty dumb. Brody has to be the kill. This is like when Renji survived like 3 turns after being caught red handed. We have nothing else to go on.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

I don't see how this applies here. If we go by Rob's plan we will know instantly if Brodeur is lying and we won't even have to lynch him because he'll be dead.

He could be a mafia roleblocker, brah.

[Brodeur]

Originally Posted by Rob S

This just strikes me as pretty dumb. Brody has to be the kill. This is like when Renji survived like 3 turns after being caught red handed. We have nothing else to go on.

I got caught doing nothing, I jailkept you for a night. You people are acting like I got caught killing libid or something. Killing me will give you absolutely nothing, I promise you that. I don't know what more I'm supposed to do here, but Gonzo's logic is so beyond ******** that I'm not sure what it'll take for someone to lynch him.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

I got caught doing nothing, I jailkept you for a night. You people are acting like I got caught killing libid or something. Killing me will give you absolutely nothing, I promise you that. I don't know what more I'm supposed to do here, but Gonzo's logic is so beyond ******** that I'm not sure what it'll take for someone to lynch him.

Seriously, you can't do anything and it's very possible you just got caught in a bad situation, but you are the obvious lynch. If we play logically, you die.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Why lynch me Brodeur? Did I not track you? Who would you jailkeep tonight if you were to remain alive?

Those who haven't voted, do so or give us other options.