SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[CashmoneyDrew]

Hmmm... someone wanna give me cliff notes on the last, oh say 25ish pages?

[Brodeur]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

Are you opposed to lynching TH then?

I'm not totally for or against it, but I won't jump on the bandwagon to lynch him to save myself. I could have earlier and the day would be over, but I didn't.

[Gay Ork Wang]

at this point, i probably be almost the most comfortable with both dead

[Snicho]

We shouldn't be adding a third name into this ********, it should be between Brody and TH considering we have info to go off for them... We have nothing on Bulldogs. Many people have already stated that everyone is suspicious in the first couple days. Going after Bulldogs is just like another random lynch on the first day.

[TitanHope]

Originally Posted by CashmoneyDrew

Hmmm... someone wanna give me cliff notes on the last, oh say 25ish pages?

A lynch train on me started around pg. 40, so that's a good place to start skimming. Basically, the vote is either for me because I'm either a) a bluffing SK or b) a vigilante that'll do more harm than good, or it's for Brody because he, according to Rob and Gonzo's testimony, blocked Rob's action. There's been a recent charge for Bulldogs because he's been suspicious to some as far as pure posting goes.

[Brodeur]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

at this point, i probably be almost the most comfortable with both dead

You just want me dead because I'm Jewish.

[Gay Ork Wang]

I didnt even know that. Now im definitely not changing my vote

[CashmoneyDrew]

Unvote: OSU

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 30 members remaining, 16 votes are needed for a majority:

Bulldogs (9) - Jensen, Brodeur, Jvig, fenikz, Woot, Dr. Gonzo, Titanhope, vidae, Forenci

TitanHope (8) - Brothgar, CJSchneider, TBW, Rufus, Todd Bertuzzi, scotty, McGee, Snicho,

Brodeur (7) – GOW, Bulldogs, Caddy, Rob S, BeerBaron, Deep, vikes,


OSUGiants (1) - ATLDirtyBirds,


CJSchneider (1) - jrdrylie


If no majority is reached by 6:30 AM EST, the top two votegetters will be lynched.

[Rob S]

Alright. I'm on a layover in phx on phone. Can't type anything lengthy, but is it not completely asinine to anyone else that we might kill bulldogs over someone confirmed with role locking powers as well as a confirmed killer? Seriously, the ****, guys?

[Gay Ork Wang]

my thoughts exactly

[vidae]

I switched my vote because I'm sick of this day not progressing. I still think TH is the smartest play here (sorry buddy, you know I love you) but we were never going to reach a majority on him so I thought we could actually, you know, move this day along if everyone agreed on someone.

This is a bigger hassle than before, and we have to solve it soon otherwise we're going to kill multiple people today.

[Brodeur]

Again Rob, voting for a suspicious guy beats voting for a guy who has not lied a single time and has played the exact same despite every single thing thrown at him. It's part of being the best in the world.

[Rob S]

I just don't see how the town could be idiotic enough to not go for Brody or TH. I'll change to TH because I get the feeling he would be the preferred lynch (of the only 2 we should even be considering).

unvote: Brody

Vote: TH

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

Again Rob, voting for a suspicious guy beats voting for a guy who has not lied a single time and has played the exact same despite every single thing thrown at him. It's part of being the best in the world.

No, it's really not. Honestly, lets assume you're good. Fine, a jail keeper can be useful. Even if TH is who he says he is, he is a detriment to the town. And, you know, there's a solid chance he is a SK and we could all but lock up the game. You're getting on your high horse here embracing your hunch over logic. Playing the gonzo role well, I admit, but following you on this one is absolutely the opposite of what this town needs.

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 30 members remaining, 16 votes are needed for a majority:

TitanHope (10) - Brothgar, CJSchneider, TBW, Rufus, Todd Bertuzzi, scotty, McGee, Snicho, Rob S, vidae

Bulldogs (8) - Jensen, Brodeur, Jvig, fenikz, Woot, Dr. Gonzo, Titanhope, Forenci


Brodeur (6) – GOW, Bulldogs, Caddy, BeerBaron, Deep, vikes,


OSUGiants (1) - ATLDirtyBirds,


CJSchneider (1) - jrdrylie


If no majority is reached by 6:30 AM EST, the top two votegetters will be lynched.

[vidae]

unvote : Bulldogs

vote : TH

Sorry, this is the best play. I believed it ten hours ago and I still believe it. My vote will likely not be changing again. And we need to come to a consensus soon. People are going to start going to bed.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by Rob S

No, it's really not. Honestly, lets assume you're good. Fine, a jail keeper can be useful. Even if TH is who he says he is, he is a detriment to the town. And, you know, there's a solid chance he is a SK and we could all but lock up the game. You're getting on your high horse here embracing your hunch over logic. Playing the gonzo role well, I admit, but following you on this one is absolutely the opposite of what this town needs.

**** you, I don't call everyone an idiot who disagrees and I always answer things asked of me and lay out how I can help the town. I am a ******* legend.

[Rob S]

Please just make sure the kill is TH or Brody tonight. No other option is logical. Don't **** this up.

[Jensen]

Both Brody and TH could be useful down the road. I don't like lynching either one of them since I think they're both good. No matter what way you guys want to spin it it's never a "logical" choice to lynch someone town-aligned. TH could hit on somebody that's bulletproof, he could be roleblocked, he could hit on somebody jailkept by Brody (if he's jailkeeper), he could kill a mafia. Just cause the chances aren't high doesn't mean it can't happen.

[vidae]

Yeah but why risk the chances that he kills someone who is good, with a very important power?

If TH lives and he takes out a Bodyguard/Doctor or an Investigator by accident, how forgiving with we be? Why even take that chance?

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by Jensen

Both Brody and TH could be useful down the road. I don't like lynching either one of them since I think they're both good. No matter what way you guys want to spin it it's never a "logical" choice to lynch someone town-aligned. TH could hit on somebody that's bulletproof, he could be roleblocked, he could hit on somebody jailkept by Brody (if he's jailkeeper), he could kill a mafia. Just cause the chances aren't high doesn't mean it can't happen.

Ok...but what's best for the town? TH is basically a town aligned SK since he is forced to kill every night. It is the logical choices because as you mentioned chances are he will hit on a town member, and the longer we keep him around, the more town aligned players he is likely to take out. It is addition by subtraction.

[Rob S]

God dammit, guys. Seriously?

[Jensen]

Originally Posted by Rob S

God dammit, guys. Seriously?

seriously.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

This should have been wrapped up 8 hours ago...