Russell Wilson vs. Sam Bradford

[Swoll_Cat]

who would you rather have right now? im not asking who would you rather have in the future/equipped with more upside or whose more proven. simply put, if you were in dire need of a starting quarterback and you could insert one of the two who would it be?

[Bengalsrocket]

Another "Russel Wilson vs." thread. Next up, Russel Wilson vs. The Incredible Hulk!

[Ness]

Russell Wilson. He's shown some potential thus far just as a rookie and might develop into a good quarterback in a couple of years. He might never be a big stat guy, and that's fine. Wilson has shown a knack for making plays though when they need to be made, a failmary not withstanding.

I've never been impressed with Sam Bradford and I think he gets another year or two in St.Louis before the Rams decide to move on.

[stlouisfan37]

I take Bradford. I think he is steadily building his confidence and maturing. Getting better every week. Honestly I think he just needs one awesome come-from-behind game-winning drive to start realizing his own potential.

[niel89]

Bradford, no question. I don't have to modify my offense as much as I would with Wilson. Put Bradford in Wilson's situation and I think he outperforms him.

Also, Hulk no question. He could even pull double duty at DE!

[armageddon]

Give Bradford a true #1 WR and he will become upper echelon quickly. How many QB's would succeed with rookie 4th rounder Chris Givens as your main target most of the year?

[regoob2]

Originally Posted by armageddon

Give Bradford a true #1 WR and he will become upper echelon quickly. How many QB's would succeed with rookie 4th rounder Chris Givens as your main target most of the year?

Has Quick played at all?

[Razor]

Originally Posted by niel89

Also, Hulk no question. He could even pull double duty at DE!

No way, he doesn't know what the quarterback is thinking like other HoF DEs playing another position...

[armageddon]

Originally Posted by regoob2

Has Quick played at all?

Barely. He hasn't grasped the playbook yet. Coming from A-State (without a playbook) to the NFL was a huge leap for him. They love his raw skills, but he is a project. 6'4, 225, good hands, can leap, fast. He has everything you look for. I hear his practices are improving a lot.

[Halsey]

Johnny Manziel

[Gay Ork Wang]

Next up:

Russel Wilson vs SHAQ

[Brent]

Originally Posted by Halsey

Johnny Manziel

[49erNation85]

Yea seriously another one ?

[armageddon]

This will be an interesting debate these next couple years between these 2 divisional rivals. Throw in Kaepernick too.

[njx9]

i'm pretty sure i'd take russell wilson over tom brady.

[armageddon]

Originally Posted by njx9

i'm pretty sure i'd take russell wilson over tom brady.

In 5 years I would too

[njx9]

Originally Posted by armageddon

In 5 years I would too

Originally Posted by Swoll_Cat

who would you rather have right now? im not asking who would you rather have in the future/equipped with more upside or whose more proven.

and i'd still probably rather have a 40 year old tom brady.

[armageddon]

Originally Posted by njx9

and i'd still probably rather have a 40 year old tom brady.

haha. Will he pull a Favre? If anyone can, it's Brady. Eh, Peyton too. The 2 best QB's of all time imo.

[Babylon]

Originally Posted by Halsey

Johnny Manziel

So Russell Wilson proves you don't have to be 6-4 to play the position and his mobility if used the right way can be a challenge to NFL defenses. Enter Johnny Manziel.

[Caulibflower]

Originally Posted by Babylon

So Russell Wilson proves you don't have to be 6-4 to play the position and his mobility if used the right way can be a challenge to NFL defenses. Enter Johnny Manziel.

Who will again prove that you have to have mastered the fundamentals in order to succeed in the NFL. :-D

I like Manziel, though. We'll see how he looks in another year. He's basically an anomaly.

[descendency]

Originally Posted by njx9

i'm pretty sure i'd take russell wilson over tom brady.

So would a lot of men.

[brat316]

Wilson is making the most of his talents and has sharpend them and made the most of them to this point. If Bradford or half the other qb do this, they would be doing just as well. He knows he is short, but he finds ways around it by improving other areas of his game.

This guy takes his game prep to a whole nother level.

If Jonny Football does the same thing, he'll be amazing. But sometimes guys use the crutch of their own talent, rather than prefecting or mastering it.

[Babylon]

Originally Posted by descendency

So would a lot of men.

Where it counts most Brady seems popular with the women.