SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[Gay Ork Wang]

is there any chance that he is a cop that gets the results confused?

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

We should probably wait to hear from Gonzo since he might have used his watch on someone.

He be deaded.

[Gay Ork Wang]

unlynch

im waiting for TBW

[vidae]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

is there any chance that he is a cop that gets the results confused?

Is there a chance? Sure, but I dunno how big of one. Damix isn't the type of guy to get confused about stuff (at least for as well as I know him anyway) so I don't buy it. I do buy the Damix role as a Mafia safeclaim though.. that is kinda where I'm at with all of this.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by vidae

He be deaded.

Damn haha I read that as CJ was dead and not Gonzo.

[Gay Ork Wang]

Originally Posted by vidae

Is there a chance? Sure, but I dunno how big of one. Damix isn't the type of guy to get confused about stuff (at least for as well as I know him anyway) so I don't buy it. I do buy the Damix role as a Mafia safeclaim though.. that is kinda where I'm at with all of this.

to be fair, you could argue his computers mess up or something

[vidae]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

to be fair, you could argue his computers mess up or something

Meh, I guess. I dunno though, still not sure I buy it.

He isn't in danger of being lynched just yet tho, so we can wait to hear from a few more people before we definitively decide anything.

[Gay Ork Wang]

btw i love how suddenly everyone just jumped on that bandwagon and said they always thought im suspicious. totally sexist against female asians.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

btw i love how suddenly everyone just jumped on that bandwagon and said they always thought im suspicious. totally sexist against female asians.

You're suspicious every game, duh.

[Gay Ork Wang]

its just, you were basically the only one who said im suspicious before today. Suddenly gang rape.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

btw i love how suddenly everyone just jumped on that bandwagon and said they always thought im suspicious. totally sexist against female asians.

That's surprising because based on the Hot Chick Thread, I though this was a board who loves their women Asian.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by vidae

You're suspicious every game, duh.

What are your thoughts on Brodeur ATL?

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

What are your thoughts on Brodeur ATL?

I could see ATL being evil, but he hasn't really posted enough for me to get a real idea one way or the other. I honestly don't remember how he plays when he's Mafia OR Town, so I really don't know. Nothing would surprise me with him.

[jrdrylie]

When ATL is a powerless townie, he doesn't participate much. However, BB said that a few times. Maybe he was protecting his mafia buddy but I think he's too smart to do that.

[Rob S]

I honestly have no read on ATL. OSU, I don't necessarily have a read on, I know he has been playing an annoying style though.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

When ATL is a powerless townie, he doesn't participate much. However, BB said that a few times. Maybe he was protecting his mafia buddy but I think he's too smart to do that.

A lot of people are like that too. I think townie is kind of fun, because you can mix it up and do whatever you want with it, but to each his own.

[Gay Ork Wang]

OSU is the gifter no?

[vidae]

OSU said he gave something to Gonzo and Gonzo confirmed that, but I don't think we ever found out what it did?

[Jensen]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

OSU is the gifter no?

based off of gonzo's posts yes, but it was kind of idiotic the way he went about it.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by vidae

A lot of people are like that too. I think townie is kind of fun, because you can mix it up and do whatever you want with it, but to each his own.

Me too. As a townie, it doesn't really matter if you did, so you can have more fun with it. As mafia or a power role, you have to be much more careful with how you play.

[Rob S]

Yeah, true. OSU is good...forgot the gifter part. He still has played like a dumbass.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

I'm in for what looks like a busy day of work. And I'm going to busy after work.

I was looking back at the end of the day yesterday to see who some of the last votes were that led to that clusterfuck. And they were TH and Bulldogs basically ******* themselves to make sure 3 people died.... Prior to that, the last vote was OSU for BD.

Also, TBW with this gem was fun:


I'm going to have to concur with what I've seen a few other people as well. I just don't have a great read on anyone right now. I'm moderately suspicious of like 3/4 of the people in the game but I'm not especially strong on any of them.

Generally, something I've noticed from modding quite a few games, is that looking at the bottom 5 or so posters and top 5 or so posters will turn up a good portion of the mafia. A lot of guys tend to lay lower and more conservatively when mafia, but there are always a few who really decide to lead the charge in discussion as well. You would think that guys would learn from these trends and try to change it up, but in every game I've been involved with, this pattern seems to hold true.

Top 5:
Gonzo
Todd
JR
Woot
CMD

Bottom 5:
Deep
SP (just started the game)
ATL
R4L
TBW

The top 5 is tough because a few of those guys are always tough to read. Gonzo posts an insane amount seemingly no matter what alignment he is. Woot is equally hard to decipher. If I had to take a stab at someone being mafia out of that group other than those two, I would guess Todd, but any argument would be extremely weak at this point.

Bottom 5 is more interesting. SuperPacker has been in the game for a day and already has more posts than Deep. R4L is pulling the school excuse for being busy. As we've discovered before, guys may be legitimately busy but it doesn't mean a thing about their alignment. Like I've said before, ATL strikes me more as "lazy townie ATL" than evil ATL, because he's usually far more malicious when evil. (Of if he just has a power of any kind.) TBW strikes me as a little off because he was one of the last group of guys to cast his vote yesterday, basically furthering that clusterfuck that led to a 3-way tie and worked out well for the mafia.

Rob has some votes, and I can see that a little bit. Him simply confirming that he was blocked by Brodeur yesterday doesn't do a damn thing to prove his alignment. He could easily be a mafia member with a power too. Still, any kind of evidence is scant.

JR strikes me as good JR that I've seen before. Posts a lot, kind of wishy-washy...I'm not getting an evil vibe there, but maybe he's just changed up how he plays a bit.

Vidae also doesn't strike me as classic evil vidae. Maybe if he gets some votes and flies into that yelling and screaming mode he will, but right now, he's playing more reserved.

Right now, gun to my head, if I had to vote, I'd pick someone from this group:

OSU - helped lead to that clusterfuck last night and has been sketchy the entire time, posting the most when there is pressure on him.

TBW - Another guy with a sketchy vibe, bottom 5 post count, and also voted late last night.

Broth - Only slightly out of the bottom 5, he is typically more active than this. Also, the lack of broth ups thus far points to a more calculated, mafia style of play.

And then there are the guys you can pretty easily forget about even being in the game. They post apparently, but their contributions aren't particuarly noteworthy like Snicho, Forenci, Jensen, Rufus...

It's going to be a gut feeling kind of day it seems.

For everyone's info....BB's last big post before he died.

[Rob S]

Definitely a veiled defense of ATL in there.

[Jensen]

Originally Posted by Rob S

Yeah, true. OSU is good...forgot the gifter part. He still has played like a dumbass.

yep, definitely causing royal pains for some people.

[jrdrylie]

So BB talks about OSU, TBW, Broth, Snicho, Forenci, Jensen, and Rufus. I'd say at least one of those is evil.