SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Shane P. Hallam

See the opening post of the day

Didn't see that, sorry. Anyway, I'll be out.

[jrdrylie]

I'm out for a few hours. Have to go get lunch, do some grocery shopping, and start cooking dinner. I'll be back by 3:30 eastern. But for now

vote CJ

[SuperPacker]

This could've been mentioned, but if CMD is a miller I dont think it would matter whether R4L was competent or incompetent. Wouldn't he come back as evil no matter what?

People jumping on that GOW train was kinda weird. Isn't everyone believing TBW as the thief and if so had GOW been evil TBW wouldn't have got the panties.

Vote: R4L

[CashmoneyDrew]

My role isn't called Miller by the way. I'm a 1 x cheat.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

This could've been mentioned, but if CMD is a miller I dont think it would matter whether R4L was competent or incompetent. Wouldn't he come back as evil no matter what?

People jumping on that GOW train was kinda weird. Isn't everyone believing TBW as the thief and if so had GOW been evil TBW wouldn't have got the panties.

Vote: R4L

If R4L gets the opposite results as we're assuming CMD would come back good. It's a good point about Renji though. Would TBW receive a gift that hints at Renji's safeclaim, or would the gift hint at his actual character were he mafia. I think that's enough to clear Renji and like I said earlier I'll buy CMD and R4L as good because it all checks out.

[Forenci]

Originally Posted by Cutey Wooty

ATL/Forenci/OSU/Deep are staying low profile. I dislike that.

Meh, I always do that. It's how I play. I actually was fairly active early on, but between finals and the stomach flu it tailed off a bit.

[Gay Ork Wang]

yay im kinda cleared

also im still very suspicious of vidae. Seems to jump on most lynchtrains

[Rob S]

For me, I think it is R4L or ATL. Do we want to go for the trivia today? I vote no.

[SuperPacker]

Vidae, Wooty and Rob all jumped on that GOW train without a second of thought.

Rob claiming that he won the trivia and decided not to use it shouldnt clear him. It wouldn't be hard for him to come up with that plan as a mafia..

[Todd Bertuzzi]

I have the cheat but I won't be here haha so I'll say no.

Now that Renji and CMD are in essence "cleared" I'm willing to leave R4L for the time being and take a shot on ATL. The fact that R4L's investigation on CMD came back as for the town either tells us that R4L gets random results or he gets the opposite results. I'm willing to give him another night to test that theory because if it is in fact the opposite he could be invaluable to us.

[Rob S]

I can get behind taking a shot with ATL.

unvote: R4L

vote: ATL

[SuperPacker]

If we aren't going for R4L, i'd probably go with vidae over ATL.

[Gay Ork Wang]

what superpacker said.

lynch vidae

[Rob S]

I'd definitely lynch ATL before vidae. I honestly don't really see why Vid is suspicious.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Woot, was your role x-shot?

[Wootylicous]

Nope I was just blocked the last two shots. I assume Caddy roleblocked me.

[Brothgar]

Me and my epic mustache are not sure. Rob has protected Gonzo several times that doesn't seem very mafia like. Although confirming that he was blocked he said himself "didn't prove he was good" kind of a strange thing for someone to say.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Brothgar

Me and my epic mustache are not sure. Rob has protected Gonzo several times that doesn't seem very mafia like. Although confirming that he was blocked he said himself "didn't prove he was good" kind of a strange thing for someone to say.

Why is that strange? Me being blocked night 1 didn't prove anything regarding my alignment. It did prove Gonzo's though.

[Jvig43]

Well I look like a douche bag now for accusing Renji all game.......awkward.

[Raiderz4Life]

I can get behind ATL, and hopefully I can get another shot to prove to y'all that I is telling the truth

[vidae]

I'm not evil at all, and please stop with the "jumped on lynch train" BS. I was the first person in the entire game to point out Renji as being suspicious to me, but now I jumped on his lynch train?

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by Rob S

Why is that strange? Me being blocked night 1 didn't prove anything regarding my alignment. It did prove Gonzo's though.

I don't believe you are mafia. But usually people are animate about not even suggesting they may have any % chance of being bad.

[SuperPacker]

I'm always suspicious of vid, but it's for different reasons this time. He just seems content to go along and jump on any train that has a little momentum. It's not classic evil vidae, but I think vidae could still be evil.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

I'm always suspicious of vid, but it's for different reasons this time. He just seems content to go along and jump on any train that has a little momentum. It's not classic evil vidae, but I think vidae could still be evil.

I have literally not done this once the entire game, haha. I have given my reasons and even led the discussion for a few different people. I haven't jumped on a lynch train once, but okay SP.

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by vidae

I have literally not done this once the entire game, haha. I have given my reasons and even led the discussion for a few different people. I haven't jumped on a lynch train once, but okay SP.

One hint of Renji possibly being evil and you're all over it. Wouldn't a townie think it through first making sure the evidence stacks up right? This isn't the vidae we're used too. Scott Wright has made a wonderful site, it should be protected from imposters like you!