SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!) - Page 88

RufusMcDaniel · 12-10-2012, 12:32 PM

From my deep research....I say we head towards Forenci.

Why? Well if you insist....

I'm not going to say because he'z inactive or any of that jazz....because I've probably been worse.

First day he mentions that OSU always plays evil, even when he is blatantly good...not going to go out and look back, but I'm not sure how someone looks that way on day 1.

My main gripe with him is the whole day 2 ordeal. He was all about lynching TH, and brought up reasons that I was behind as well. Defended this choice against Woot, and didn't understand Woot's logic behind voting Brodeur, even though we did have information on him but not Bulldogs. But once others hopped aboard the Bulldogs bandwagon...he got on. Even while he still believed that TH was the most logical choice. Then, when Caddy asked why everyone is voting for Bulldogs, his response was because he is sketchy.

The next day he kept calling out OSU for the random vote and being responsible for the three way tie, and in general was after OSU for the most part. But for the sake of unity he voted Snicho.

Lastly, his third most recent post....

Quote:

Originally Posted by Forenci

Meh, I'm never for killing inactives. I'd rather just go with our best and most logical guess.

Goes against everything he did Day 2.

I'm not guaranteeing that he is a mafia member or even SK, but he is my best guess.

Vote: Forenci

Tiquan Underwood.

Shane P. Hallam · 12-10-2012, 12:38 PM

With 18 user remaining, 10 are needed for a majority

Jensen (5) – vidae, Snicho, Forenci, vikes_28, jrdrylie

Forenci (1) - Rufus

SuperPacker (1) - Scotty

scottyboy · 12-10-2012, 12:44 PM

i'll have to look into forenci, but Rufus, if you really are me, I'm disappointed you just went on forenci rant and didn't mention how much you hate uconn/uconn sucks. I'm a little disappoint

vidae · 12-10-2012, 12:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scottyboy

i'll have to look into forenci, but Rufus, if you really are me, I'm disappointed you just went on forenci rant and didn't mention how much you hate uconn/uconn sucks. I'm a little disappoint

I would have made the BEST Scotty in the world. Opportunities lost.. sighhh :(

Also, TBW has 30 posts.. so we might be waiting a while to find out if he knows anything. It might be in our best interest to stop waiting on someone who is so inactive.

RufusMcDaniel · 12-10-2012, 12:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RufusMcDaniel

Forenci would be a good choice, based just on his UConn allegiance.

I tried that before scotty, no one got on the train :(...so I tried to develop a theory.

DeepThreat · 12-10-2012, 01:14 PM

Guys, I never once claimed Grizz, so everyone saying that is ******* ********. I'm diab. Grizz isn't the only married person on here.

scottyboy · 12-10-2012, 01:16 PM

meh. that like just happened, didn't it? and diab doesn't post about his wife as much as grizz I feel. Is that your role? to post about your wife everyday? eh.

DeepThreat · 12-10-2012, 01:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scottyboy

meh. that like just happened, didn't it? and diab doesn't post about his wife as much as grizz I feel. Is that your role? to post about your wife everyday? eh.

Yes, it is. And why would it make any sense for me to lie here? I just decided to post about my wife everyday?

Forenci · 12-10-2012, 01:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RufusMcDaniel

From my deep research....I say we head towards Forenci.

Why? Well if you insist....

I'm not going to say because he'z inactive or any of that jazz....because I've probably been worse.

First day he mentions that OSU always plays evil, even when he is blatantly good...not going to go out and look back, but I'm not sure how someone looks that way on day 1.

My main gripe with him is the whole day 2 ordeal. He was all about lynching TH, and brought up reasons that I was behind as well. Defended this choice against Woot, and didn't understand Woot's logic behind voting Brodeur, even though we did have information on him but not Bulldogs. But once others hopped aboard the Bulldogs bandwagon...he got on. Even while he still believed that TH was the most logical choice. Then, when Caddy asked why everyone is voting for Bulldogs, his response was because he is sketchy.

The next day he kept calling out OSU for the random vote and being responsible for the three way tie, and in general was after OSU for the most part. But for the sake of unity he voted Snicho.

Lastly, his third most recent post....

Goes against everything he did Day 2.

I'm not guaranteeing that he is a mafia member or even SK, but he is my best guess.

Vote: Forenci

Tiquan Underwood.

Numerous things wrong with this. First, as I've said before, I always think Bulldogs and OSU are sketchy because of how they play. Last time I tried to protect OSU in a game by saying it was "just OSU being OSU" he turned out to be evil so now I stay suspicious of him.

Second, I don't trust Bulldogs and always feel he's sketchy. He's too good of a player and knows how to play mafia really damn well. I still felt TH was our best bet, I mainly just wanted to ensure multiple people weren't going to die and it seemed Bulldogs would bite the bullet.

I'm not sure about the whole Woot thing as an argument. Woot was making a terrible and highly illogical argument saying how we should let TH kill someone because "odds he'll have a good chance" when odds were he'd just just kill a townie. I'm pretty sure I said I would have rather stuck with TH but I didn't want multiple people dying because we couldn't make a decision.

I must've have missed where OSU was not being bad. I know he said he could prove his innocence but I never saw it.

Also, I don't see how that post goes against everything I said the night before?

Forenci · 12-10-2012, 01:23 PM

And apologies on the double posts but I'm heading out to take my final and then go to work (where I might try to hop on here for a few but it's TBD).

Shane P. Hallam · 12-10-2012, 01:50 PM

Sports Challenge Time!

There is still an unsolved Sports Challenge! Where did the stolen Lombardi Trophy go? Someone has to find it and PM me the link to it!

Hints:

1: It is in the 2013 NFL Draft Forum

2: The thread was started by a banned user (and the Lombardi trophy is spoilered in that post!)

3: This banned user is not in our game!

GO FIND IT! WINNER GETS A KILL TONIGHT!

RufusMcDaniel · 12-10-2012, 01:58 PM

So, you felt that TH was the best option that night, and I agreed with you (didn't say anything but I shared similar thoughts), yet you jumped over to Bulldogs, without any information out about him other than being sketchy. You may have wanted to ensure to multiple people didn't die, but you didn't have to switch the vote, it's not like TH lost all the votes he had.

I said that it goes against what you did on Night 2, because the reasoning behind lynching TH was more logical than taking out Bulldogs. And yes Bulldogs is a good player, thus I could see the reason to jump on a chance to get him out of this.

As for OSU, I'm just repeating what you said....all the stuff I stated was based on your posts in this thread.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Forenci

I don't know how OSU does it but he always manages to somehow play evil. Even when he's blatantly good.

Although I did make a mistake, this was on day 2, not 1....so let me correct that error.

scottyboy · 12-10-2012, 02:16 PM

jbond you are a liar.

Rob S · 12-10-2012, 02:35 PM

Damn. We really need to stop letting these go to trivia. So annoying.

jrdrylie · 12-10-2012, 02:49 PM

Yeah, and we should be stopping wait for TBW. He gone nearly entires day with not posts. Don't feel like wait for him anymore.

SuperPacker · 12-10-2012, 02:51 PM

Well we're definitely waiting for TBW.

Jensen makes sense, though i'm not 100% confident in either R4L getting opposite results or him even being good. Jensen claims to be only a townie, so if we're going to test whether R4L's results can be trusted, he would make the most sense to try it on. And best case scenario we kill a mafia.

Quote:

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

Yeah, and we should be stopping wait for TBW. He gone nearly entires day with not posts. Don't feel like wait for him anymore.

Should we really do something that wouldn't help the town, because we're running out of patience. If he's mafia, that's exactly what he'd want us to do.

OSUGiants17 · 12-10-2012, 02:56 PM

So I'm trying to figure out why we are going after Jensen. R4L's investigations haven't all been flipped, have they? If they all have been then I am fine with Jensen, but I don't think they have been. To me SP seems like a better bet with his unnecessary defense of ATL, but I will wait for TBW to show up.

SuperPacker · 12-10-2012, 02:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

So I'm trying to figure out why we are going after Jensen. R4L's investigations haven't all been flipped, have they? If they all have been then I am fine with Jensen, but I don't think they have been. To me SP seems like a better bet with his unnecessary defense of ATL, but I will wait for TBW to show up.

Assuming CMD would come back as good as a miller or whatever he is, then yes.

Rob S · 12-10-2012, 02:59 PM

I don't necessarily believe that R4L can even investigate. I have no idea why Damix would be a cop. That said, I'm voting SP....Shane as a townie makes absolutely no sense to me. None.

vote: lynch SP

Jensen · 12-10-2012, 03:00 PM

because r4l's investigation showed me to be good and everybody thinks his results are reversed, if he's even an investigator. that's pretty impressive that 2 investigators have lasted 2 nights in a row now.

CashmoneyDrew · 12-10-2012, 03:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob S

I don't necessarily believe that R4L can even investigate. I have no idea why Damix would be a cop. That said, I'm voting SP....Shane as a townie makes absolutely no sense to me. None.

vote: lynch SP

I think if you're going to go by that logic, then it would make more sense to go after R4L. I find it more likely Shane would go the humble route and make himself a townie than Damix would actually be incompetent or whatever.

At this point I think R4L could be the godfather.

scottyboy · 12-10-2012, 03:09 PM

yeah, there's just something not adding up with R4L and SP's roles.

Shane P. Hallam · 12-10-2012, 03:13 PM

With 18 user remaining, 10 are needed for a majority

Jensen (5) – vidae, Snicho, Forenci, vikes_28, jrdrylie

SuperPacker (1) - Scotty, Rob S.

Forenci (1) - Rufus

Wootylicous · 12-10-2012, 03:18 PM

I'm still waiting on TBW...if he doesn't talk soon I will have to ban his ass.

Rob S · 12-10-2012, 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CashmoneyDrew

I think if you're going to go by that logic, then it would make more sense to go after R4L. I find it more likely Shane would go the humble route and make himself a townie than Damix would actually be incompetent or whatever.

At this point I think R4L could be the godfather.

Honestly, wouldn't be shocked if both were mafia. Coupled with his defense of ATL, I'll stand by my SP vote.