SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[Jensen]

also, i find it interesting that R4L investigated me and it came back good, yet he still voted for me. you would think he knows what his role is well enough to trust his results. which means he either knows what type of investigator he is and is not telling us, or he's not an investigator.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by Jensen

well, i don't know what to tell you then. he's not an incompetent investigator, that's all i can give you. there's no framer left so there's no way he can dispute the result if i get lynched and he's still here tomorrow. your guys' choice.

Well by lynching you we will find out if he's lying or not. If we lynch him straight up we risk losing a possible source of info for the town but with you we're just risking losing a townie. It sucks but if you are in fact good you'd be taking one for the team here when R4L is exposed.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

Alright well then I don't think we have another option outside of Jensen. Wish TBW wasn't taking his sweet ass time...

I think we should just kill R4L. If Jensen turns out good, Raiderz will just claim random results and we'll be in the same boat tomorrow and down a townie. Throw in the CMD claim and this is a massive clusterfuck.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by Rob S

I think we should just kill R4L. If Jensen turns out good, Raiderz will just claim random results and we'll be in the same boat tomorrow and down a townie. Throw in the CMD claim and this is a massive clusterfuck.

I see where you're going with this but lynching R4L might not help either. Maybe his role is just investigator and even if when he dies, we aren't told whether his results are correct, reverse, or random.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by Rob S

I think we should just kill R4L. If Jensen turns out good, Raiderz will just claim random results and we'll be in the same boat tomorrow and down a townie. Throw in the CMD claim and this is a massive clusterfuck.

I think we lynch Jensen and best case is he's mafia, worst case R4L played us and we lynch him tomorrow with only a townie sacrificed to nab a mafia. Give me that trade off 10 times out of 10.

[Todd Bertuzzi]

If CMD says it states that explicitly in his role his is either covering his ass or it actually does say that. Either way it gives us reason to trust R4L and the lynching of Jensen will confirm any theories we have. I don't think it would be smart to lynch an investigator when there is a better play available.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

I think we lynch Jensen and best case is he's mafia, worst case R4L played us and we lynch him tomorrow with only a townie sacrificed to nab a mafia. Give me that trade off 10 times out of 10.

But if Jensen is good, Raiderz isn't an obvious lynch.....he may just be getting random results.

[Jensen]

Originally Posted by Jensen

also, i find it interesting that R4L investigated me and it came back good, yet he still voted for me. you would think he knows what his role is well enough to trust his results. which means he either knows what type of investigator he is and is not telling us, or he's not an investigator.

you know what, i convinced myself. you guys can go ahead and lynch me if you want though.

Vote: R4L

[Todd Bertuzzi]

Originally Posted by Rob S

But if Jensen is good, Raiderz isn't an obvious lynch.....he may just be getting random results.

It's a chance we'll have to take. If CMD's claim is true then all of his results have been exactly the opposite so far and we have no reason not to follow him on this one.

[vidae]

I don't really see another choice here.

vote : Jensen

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Todd Bertuzzi

It's a chance we'll have to take. If CMD's claim is true then all of his results have been exactly the opposite so far and we have no reason not to follow him on this one.

I guess. I'll just have to ignore my gut on this one I suppose.

vote: jensen

Also, can we please get the day done before trivia tomorrow? TBW sucks at posting and we can't keep waiting for him risking an extra death every night.

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 18 user remaining, 10 are needed for a majority

Jensen (7) – Snicho, Forenci, vikes_28, jrdrylie, R4L, vidae, Rob S

SuperPacker (1) - Scotty,

DeepThreat (1) - Woot

Forenci (1) - Rufus

R4L (1) -Jensen

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Rob S

Also, can we please get the day done before trivia tomorrow? TBW sucks at posting and we can't keep waiting for him risking an extra death every night.

So many times this.

[SuperPacker]

Slow down Joseph's. Can't we wait for TBW?

[Rob S]

We can wait for him today. **** waiting for him tomorrow though.

[CashmoneyDrew]

My dad's in town so I'm headed to dinner with him. Might check in in a few hours. I'll hold off on voting for now but I'm heavily leaning towards Jensen.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

Slow down Joseph's. Can't we wait for TBW?

We can, but like I said earlier, he has 30 total posts. We might be waiting all night.

Originally Posted by Rob S

We can wait for him today. **** waiting for him tomorrow though.

Yeah, he is an investigator of sorts, and him not being active is really kind of screwing us. And it's annoying.

[TheBoyWonder22]

Has Vidae revealed his role yet? Sorry I've just been swamped with work and finals.

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

Has Vidae revealed his role yet? Sorry I've just been swamped with work and finals.

Well what did you steal from him first?

[TheBoyWonder22]

And I posted that as you did. Sorry it's the busiest week of my life...

[jrdrylie]

Unvote Jensen

[Todd Bertuzzi]

TBW I need to hit the books here, what did you find?

[vidae]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

Well what did you steal from him first?

How do you know he stole from me?

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by vidae

How do you know he stole from me?

That just made it sound like he stole from you?

[Rob S]

If anything the person he stole from should role claim first