SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[RufusMcDaniel]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

I could actually see Vidae being the Godfather with Scott as his safe claim. But then again, I have trouble seeing Scott not being in the game. But the term Bubble Butt has been used to describe guys at the Senior Bowl on this site.

Ohhh ok, well then carry on my wayward son.

Can we work on a theory that Mel Kiper is a vampire and infecting people?

[TheBoyWonder22]

This is the only mafia game I've ever played where I don't trust anyone. I think we should take another look at CMD.

[vidae]

Scott has definitely used bubble butt a lot in the past. I'm not lying about who I am.

[CashmoneyDrew]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

This is the only mafia game I've ever played where I don't trust anyone. I think we should take another look at CMD.

Surely you can't be serious.

[TheBoyWonder22]

Yeah I've just gone through everything CMD has said and I don't like any of it. A 1x cheat who gave a cheat that didn't work. His justification for lynching Jensen was that he came up good in R4L's investigation. He apparently killed someone by winning the game at an earlier time. It just feels wrong. With that,

Vote: CashMoneyDrew

[TheBoyWonder22]

I'm just not feeling it. Maybe we should see how the whole R4L thing goes first, but with this whole losing 3 guys a night thing I'll stick with my vote.

[Shane P. Hallam]

With 13 players remaining, 7 votes are needed for a majority

Raiderz4Life (2) - DeepThreat, vidae

CashMoneyDrew (1) - TBW

[RufusMcDaniel]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

I'm just not feeling it. Maybe we should see how the whole R4L thing goes first, but with this whole losing 3 guys a night thing I'll stick with my vote.

We'll only lose two if we don't get to trivia...but it would be nice to get the SK today.

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

Yeah I've just gone through everything CMD has said and I don't like any of it. A 1x cheat who gave a cheat that didn't work. His justification for lynching Jensen was that he came up good in R4L's investigation. He apparently killed someone by winning the game at an earlier time. It just feels wrong. With that,

Vote: CashMoneyDrew

On night one, he killed a mafia member. That automatically clears him of being mafia to me. Later in the game, I could see the mafia sacrificing one of their own. But on Night one? No.

His gave his cheat to Todd, who was a confirmed good guy. Todd didn't use it becuase he was out at dinner. It's not CMD's fault. Could he be the serial killer? I suppose so, but I have never seen a serial killer have an additional power besides killing.

[TheBoyWonder22]

Originally Posted by RufusMcDaniel

We'll only lose two if we don't get to trivia...but it would be nice to get the SK today.

Who are you suspicious of?

[TheBoyWonder22]

How do we know that he's the one that killed JBalla?

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

How do we know that he's the one that killed JBalla?

Because he said he was an nobody else came out and said anything about it.

[jrdrylie]

Bahhh, I thought I just caught Deep in a lie, but I was incorrect.

[RufusMcDaniel]

Originally Posted by TheBoyWonder22

Who are you suspicious of?

R4L, Broth and vidae

[SuperPacker]

TBW why aren't you saying what you stole? And why steal from JR in the first place?

[CashmoneyDrew]

TBW's nonsense aside, I'm comfortable voting right now. Vikes is probably next on my suspicion list.

vote: lynch R4L

[SuperPacker]

Originally Posted by RufusMcDaniel

R4L, Broth and vidae

I'm basically suspicious of the same people. They'd be the first 3 I'd go after.

[DeepThreat]

My wife has me doing a bunch of **** today (studying, exams), so I don't know how much I'll be around.

[jrdrylie]

Ranked in how much I trust everyone

Good:
1 Jrdrylie-
2 OSU- Gifter
3 Snicho- Mason (I think I have seen a mafia masoned with a town person so I suppose he could be evil)
4 CMD- Cheater- Killed a mafia guy I suppose he could be the serial killer

Probably Good
5 Scotty- I have nothing on him, but if he is fenikz, he's good
6 Vidae- Says he's Scott, but wouldn't he have a power? He's given us no information so I could see him being the GF
7 TBW- Thief Still not 100% convinced he is telling the truth. If he reveals what he stole from me, it could clear him, but I don't think that is a wise idea.

50/50
8 Rufus- If I had to guess who is the serial killer, I'd say Rufus. But I have no confidence in that at all
9 Super Packer- Would a mafia member try so hard to defend ATL?
10 R4L- I was suspicious early in the game and his investigations don't make sense

Very sketchy
11 Deep- Has layed low
12 Broth- He has played a much more careful game. Good chance he's the GF
13 Vikes- Says he a tracker but we had a tracker, watcher, backup, 1X Watcher and 1X Tracker/Watcher. I doubt he is actually a tracker.

Lynch Vikes

[SuperPacker]

Where did vikes say he was a tracker?

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

Where did vikes say he was a tracker?

I don't remember it either, but it was posted on another list and it caught my eye. I'll verify it.

[Raiderz4Life]

SP is evil, was my result ladt night

[DeepThreat]

Originally Posted by Raiderz4Life

SP is evil, was my result ladt night

It's quite clear that your "results" mean nothing.

[TheBoyWonder22]

I'm not going to put the town in danger just to clear myself. So unless JR actually tells me to reveal the item which would reveal his role, I refuse.

Let's go back to CMD. On Day Two he states that the football is probably the murder weapon given to the trivia winner. This makes sense, but the weird part to me is how long it takes him after everyone tells the winner to reveal themselves to actually do so. He proceeds to clear TH as the vigilante (which idk how he would do that if his role is cheat) and finally fessed up to being the trivia winner where he coincidentally deleted his pm's and couldn't remember the answer. Along the way, he also claimed he was a Miller and is evil upon investigation.

So not only is he a cheat, he's a miller, and he clears TH which implies an investigative role. I think he risked it by claiming to be the trivia winner. I think his actual role is mafia role cop. Is this a stron claim. Certainly, but I'm not liking this story one bit.

[TheBoyWonder22]

The second to last sentence is horribly typed. ****! But you guys get my point.