Luck is a great talent. Luck will probably be a great pro QB for years to come.
Luck IMO isn't having a OROTY season.
If standard of play is being set by the other contenders for the award, I don't see how Luck's season can be seen in any way superlative to what Russell Wilson or RGIII have done.
My main argument against Luck has always been his turnovers. Maybe the Seahawks could still manage to outplay 18 INTs and 9 fumbles by their QB. I know the Skins couldn't.
The fact that the Colts have won 9 games in spite of those turnovers speaks to Luck's talents and the Colts relatively weak strength of schedule.
I don't think Luck should win it, but I'm not cutting off a finger if he does.