All NFLDC SS - Ed Reed

[America]

My top 5

1. Reed
2. Polamalu
3. Adrian Wilson
4. Roy Williams
5. Mike Brown

And to those who say Reed is bad in run support, he really isn't. He's small, and people just think because of that he's not good in run support. He's no Sean Taylor but he comes up and makes big stops. And he can lay a huge hit on guys. See Colts game ST hit and Koren Robinson hit in the Vikings-Ravens game. He makes plays from all over the field, up on the line or 30 yards downfield. He's the most complete and is the best cover guy. So he's the best IMO.

Originally Posted by nathan

Here are my top 5 rankings:

Troy Polamalu ( Very Dimensional He can do it all)
Ed Reed (He is great and can also do most of it all)
Michael Lewis ( Great Coverage safety and can come up ad make a safe tackle)
Roy Williams ( An awesome hitter and good in coverage but not great)Rodney Harrison (He is a good all around safety)

Try again son

Originally Posted by Staubach12

I'd like to say Roy Williams, but it's Ed Reed.

Thank you.

stephenson, you should call both the safety polls. if theres a comeback at this point it is because someone cheated. I cant wait for the kicker poll. its gonna be a close 3 man race

[stephenson86]

Originally Posted by cardsalltheway

stephenson, you should call both the safety polls. if theres a comeback at this point it is because someone cheated. I cant wait for the kicker poll. its gonna be a close 3 man race

i think i will, then tomorrow i can properly publish the team

[Ravens1991]

I have seen a quick flucuation in Roy Williams votes.

Originally Posted by Ravens1991

I have seen a quick flucuation in Roy Williams votes.

He has had like 2 votes in 2 hours

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

He has had like 2 votes in 2 hours

i think he meant earlier when he went from 3 to 17

[stephenson86]

Originally Posted by cardsalltheway

i think he meant earlier when he went from 3 to 17

so roy williams has had foul play regarding his votes is what ur saying?

Originally Posted by stephenson86

so roy williams has had foul play regarding his votes is what ur saying?

yea but i think he was in 2nd before that anyway. just make the kicker poll

[stephenson86]

Originally Posted by cardsalltheway

yea but i think he was in 2nd before that anyway. just make the kicker poll

i wont DQ him, as i didnt see it either

[The Great Jonathan Vilma]

when healthy. its reed, but not after last year. overall, assuming all healthy, i'd want reed

[Immaculate Tackle]

This is BS! Ed Reed is an FS. Polamalu should have won this.

[stephenson86]

Originally Posted by Immaculate Tackle

This is BS! Ed Reed is an FS. Polamalu should have won this.

shush

[draftguru151]

Originally Posted by Immaculate Tackle

This is BS! Ed Reed is an FS. Polamalu should have won this.

Reed is a SS. :?

[Ravens1991]

Ed Reed plays both, he s a SS and plays FS he can play both.

[jsagan77]

Ed Reed hands down..

How can you even vote for someone else? Williams couldn't hold Reeds Jock...

Originally Posted by Ravens1991

Ed Reed plays both, he s a SS and plays FS he can play both.

and hes the best at both

[Ravens1991]

Originally Posted by jsagan77

Ed Reed hands down..

How can you even vote for someone else? Williams couldn't hold Reeds Jock...

yea I know it makes me sick that someone would even think of voting for him


(it is sarcasm, i am saying this so people dont attack me with well Roy is preety good puts fear in every offensive player)

[RCAChainGang]

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

and hes the best at both

Troy is the best at SS, sorry.

[draftguru151]

Originally Posted by nathan

Troy is the best at SS, sorry.

:?