Who would you bench first? - Page 3

diabsoule · 09-12-2006, 12:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by smittyjs

You can't teach that.... :shock:
Go ahead and give him his MVP award. 8)

*man crush pictures of VY*

I know, his mechanics in those pictures were awesome and he is ready to hop in right now and bring the Titans to the Super Bowl!

P.S. - I was being sarcastic. He's a solid year or two away from being the QB he needs to be in order to play in the NFL.

someone447 · 09-12-2006, 01:45 PM

There is no reason to rush Rodgers into starting this year, QBs who have sat for 2 years have tended to do really well. Having Favre in the game at least gives them a chance to win. He may not be the best QB in the league anymore, but there are 15-20 teams that would take him in a heartbeat. He is still a great competitor, he still has a great arm and can make throws that most QBs can only dream of. Yes, he does throw way too many ints, but look who he has to work with... Lets see if he improves now that he will have another decent reciever in Koren Robinson. Don't write the packers off as the worst team in the league, let the line mesh and Favre get the timing with Jennings. They are FAR from a good team, but they aren't the worst in the league.

Nitschke-Hawk · 09-12-2006, 02:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TitleTown088

Quote:

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

Quote:

Originally Posted by TitleTown088

Quote:

Originally Posted by ghettosermon

Favre for sure, the Packers are going to be a horrible team no matter what so you might as well get the young guy in, but that will never happen because the Packers wouldn't have the guts to bench him.

I'd love to see the coach that benches favre is his first year as a head coach. people from wisconsin would have his head on a stake. ... PLus favre didn't really play terrible either. He was playing agianst a good defense with inexpirance all around him. The packers have 23 rookies on their roster i think. It's gonna take time before everyone gets onthe same page.

That is BS favre play horrible and you know it. Explain thoes 2 ints please.

Those two INts didn't matter the game was lost by then dude he was trying to make somthing outta nothing. and one was even all his fault it was a blown route by jennings. I'm not saying favre is the number 1 QB in the league, but look at what he's working with,(Inexpiranced players for the most part) seriously get off his nuts and give the man a few games to work with all these new faces before you tell him to throw in the towel.

I'm really getting tired of this SeanTaylor21 cat, he says explains those 2 INT's please, prolly cause he didn't watch the game, you're falling right into this perception that people (mainly Espn) are creating making him look so terrible. I admit I got pissed when he threw those interceptions cause it was just pointless, but he didn't cost us the game. But if he helped turn this thing around and had a great season these same people would be praising him(and i'm not saying tat will happen). But I am sick of it.

YoJoeBucsFan · 09-12-2006, 06:22 PM

I would put Chris Simms up there on that list.

Beans · 09-12-2006, 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by YoJoeBucsFan

I would put Chris Simms up there on that list.

Are you a Bucs hater in disguise or something? You're at least incredibly pessimistic.

09-12-2006, 06:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeansDooma

Quote:

Originally Posted by YoJoeBucsFan

I would put Chris Simms up there on that list.

Are you a Bucs hater in disguise or something? You're at least incredibly pessimistic.

if you look at his other posts its definitely a falcons fan

YoJoeBucsFan · 09-12-2006, 06:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardsalltheway

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeansDooma

Quote:

Originally Posted by YoJoeBucsFan

I would put Chris Simms up there on that list.

Are you a Bucs hater in disguise or something? You're at least incredibly pessimistic.

if you look at his other posts its definitely a falcons fan

That was LOW, I am not pessimistic, I am honest. We played like crap, got our butts handed to us after we had all preseason to get things fixed. This offseason was not good, we drafted a couple of stiffs for offensive linemen. I see things being no better next week either unless they magically learn how to block.

09-12-2006, 06:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by YoJoeBucsFan

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardsalltheway

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeansDooma

Quote:

Originally Posted by YoJoeBucsFan

I would put Chris Simms up there on that list.

Are you a Bucs hater in disguise or something? You're at least incredibly pessimistic.

if you look at his other posts its definitely a falcons fan

That was LOW, I am not pessimistic, I am honest. We played like crap, got our butts handed to us after we had all preseason to get things fixed. This offseason was not good, we drafted a couple of stiffs for offensive linemen. I see things being no better next week either unless they magically learn how to block.

dont see how you can call joseph a stiff. hes gonna be a STUD,

YoJoeBucsFan · 09-12-2006, 06:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardsalltheway

Quote:

Originally Posted by YoJoeBucsFan

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardsalltheway

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeansDooma

Quote:

Originally Posted by YoJoeBucsFan

I would put Chris Simms up there on that list.

Are you a Bucs hater in disguise or something? You're at least incredibly pessimistic.

if you look at his other posts its definitely a falcons fan

That was LOW, I am not pessimistic, I am honest. We played like crap, got our butts handed to us after we had all preseason to get things fixed. This offseason was not good, we drafted a couple of stiffs for offensive linemen. I see things being no better next week either unless they magically learn how to block.

dont see how you can call joseph a stiff. hes gonna be a STUD,

I hope you're right, I saw nothing in preseason and I never did see a thing while he was at OU to warrant a 1st round pick for him. But I guess King Jon must have fallen for him.

yodapoop · 09-12-2006, 08:54 PM

I think it is time for the G-Men to go to Jerod Lorenzon.

The Unseen · 09-12-2006, 08:55 PM

Quote:

I think it is time for the G-Men to go to Jerod Lorenzon.

Then bench Tiki for Brandon Jacobs. The I-Swolemation, baby.

Dam8610 · 09-12-2006, 08:58 PM

Tough call between Favre and Plummer. That's based on the ability of the backup though. If it were based on starter ability, Bledsoe would be the first one benched.

SuperMcGee · 09-12-2006, 09:29 PM

Get Andrew Walter in there 8)

cunningham06 · 09-12-2006, 10:33 PM

People need to stop hating on Favre, if Aaron Rodgers goes in they won't win any more games than with Favre. Favre plays to win which most people just can't handle because it means bad stats! Big deal, he protected the ball for the entire game against Chicago but in the end when he realized that their only chance was taking shots down field he tried and got picked off twice.

The first qb I would bench is not on this list and is named Kerry Collins. I would put Volek in. Even though everyone thinks he's terrible now after a bad preseason showing, he was good when he was a starter and deserves a chance this season. He at least can't be worse than Kerry Collins.

elway777 · 09-12-2006, 10:58 PM

This is the worst thread i've seen in awhile,mainly because of the options on the poll.

detknowitall · 09-13-2006, 10:24 AM

Farve should be, but it'll never happen. You cant bench Farve in Green Bay. I think the Admin wanted him to retire and were somewhat upset when he didnt. But if you bench Farve and Rogers comes in and struggles then you would look like more of a bonehead than when you benched him.

detknowitall · 09-13-2006, 10:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cunningham06

People need to stop hating on Favre, if Aaron Rodgers goes in they won't win any more games than with Favre. Favre plays to win which most people just can't handle because it means bad stats! Big deal, he protected the ball for the entire game against Chicago but in the end when he realized that their only chance was taking shots down field he tried and got picked off twice.

The first qb I would bench is not on this list and is named Kerry Collins. I would put Volek in. Even though everyone thinks he's terrible now after a bad preseason showing, he was good when he was a starter and deserves a chance this season. He at least can't be worse than Kerry Collins.

True. But they arent going to win that many WITH farve either. SO you might as well find out what you have in Aaron Rogers.

my future me · 09-13-2006, 11:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by detknowitall

Quote:

Originally Posted by cunningham06

People need to stop hating on Favre, if Aaron Rodgers goes in they won't win any more games than with Favre. Favre plays to win which most people just can't handle because it means bad stats! Big deal, he protected the ball for the entire game against Chicago but in the end when he realized that their only chance was taking shots down field he tried and got picked off twice.

The first qb I would bench is not on this list and is named Kerry Collins. I would put Volek in. Even though everyone thinks he's terrible now after a bad preseason showing, he was good when he was a starter and deserves a chance this season. He at least can't be worse than Kerry Collins.

True. But they arent going to win that many WITH farve either. SO you might as well find out what you have in Aaron Rogers.

Farve. He can't play. He was feeling pressure and rushing throws when there was nobody near him. Green Bay needs to find out what Aaron Rogers has and get him some experience playing.

PACKmanN · 09-13-2006, 12:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by YoJoeBucsFan

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardsalltheway

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeansDooma

Quote:

Originally Posted by YoJoeBucsFan

I would put Chris Simms up there on that list.

Are you a Bucs hater in disguise or something? You're at least incredibly pessimistic.

if you look at his other posts its definitely a falcons fan

That was LOW, I am not pessimistic, I am honest. We played like crap, got our butts handed to us after we had all preseason to get things fixed. This offseason was not good, we drafted a couple of stiffs for offensive linemen. I see things being no better next week either unless they magically learn how to block.

Well how could they block when both there starting OGs were out in that game?

09-13-2006, 02:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elway777

This is the worst thread i've seen in awhile,mainly because of the options on the poll.

This poll was made before the debacle of a game by Aaron Brooks.

portermvp84 · 09-13-2006, 03:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by intergalacticspacemonkey

Quote:

Originally Posted by elway777

This is the worst thread i've seen in awhile,mainly because of the options on the poll.

This poll was made before the debacle of a game by Aaron Brooks.

and clearly Aarron Brooks is horrible.

jkpigskin · 09-13-2006, 08:53 PM

get jay cutler out there!!!

though getting him in this early will make or break his career.... a la kyle boller

Boston · 09-13-2006, 08:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

Quote:

Originally Posted by TitleTown088

Quote:

Originally Posted by ghettosermon

Favre for sure, the Packers are going to be a horrible team no matter what so you might as well get the young guy in, but that will never happen because the Packers wouldn't have the guts to bench him.

I'd love to see the coach that benches favre is his first year as a head coach. people from wisconsin would have his head on a stake. ... PLus favre didn't really play terrible either. He was playing agianst a good defense with inexpirance all around him. The packers have 23 rookies on their roster i think. It's gonna take time before everyone gets onthe same page.

That is BS favre play horrible and you know it. Explain thoes 2 ints please.

Your lack of knowledge ceases to amaze me. You didn't even watch the game did you.

elway777 · 09-13-2006, 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jkpigskin

get jay cutler out there!!!

though getting him in this early will make or break his career.... a la kyle boller

Plummer did worse last year on the game opener vs. the dolphins and then had a great year,..why put a rookie in and call it quits? :?

cunningham06 · 09-13-2006, 10:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boston

Quote:

Originally Posted by SeanTaylor21

Quote:

Originally Posted by TitleTown088

Quote:

Originally Posted by ghettosermon

Favre for sure, the Packers are going to be a horrible team no matter what so you might as well get the young guy in, but that will never happen because the Packers wouldn't have the guts to bench him.

I'd love to see the coach that benches favre is his first year as a head coach. people from wisconsin would have his head on a stake. ... PLus favre didn't really play terrible either. He was playing agianst a good defense with inexpirance all around him. The packers have 23 rookies on their roster i think. It's gonna take time before everyone gets onthe same page.

That is BS favre play horrible and you know it. Explain thoes 2 ints please.

Your lack of knowledge ceases to amaze me. You didn't even watch the game did you.

Ok here's what happened, Favre was having a decent game, he wasn't making many mistakes which is all you can really ask of the Packers against the Bears. Near the end of the game (once it was 26-0 I believe) Favre tried to get the team back in the game or at least score some points, so he went for it and he got picked off twice. I'm sorry, but I respect Favre for that. I like a qb who cares more about winning than his stats. Damage control is not the job of a qb. When you're losing you should try to win! Not limit your risks so you don't potentially lose by more. Don't throw out Favre's accomplishments just because of what happened near the end of the game.