Does Al Harris deserve a Pro-Bowl bid

Moses · 12-19-2006, 07:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by njx9

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moses

Quote:

Originally Posted by njx9

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moses

Quote:

Originally Posted by njx9

Quote:

Originally Posted by Packman1957

Quote:

Originally Posted by njx9

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moses

Al Harris is not the best cornerback in the league. However, he is very goodand had an excellent season. The Pro Bowl is stupid and I don't know/care if he deserves to be in it. The point is he is a very good corner who had a very good season. I explained this all in an earlier post which was ignored for the most part.

sorry, the solid but unspectacular posts tend to get ignored. but yes, i agree with that statement.

Wait a second you agree with this statement...LOL. I thought just ten minutes ago you were just saying how Al Harris didn't have the best season. Make up your mind man. Its one or the other.

i missed the bold. fixed.

I don't really understand how you can say that Harris didn't have a good season. I challenge you to name 5 cornerbacks in the NFC who had a better season than him.

:roll:

let's be clear with our syntax. very good, good and excellent are vastly different terms. he had a good season, sure, i'll take your word for it. but, based on the stats i can see, and testimoney (previously quoted) of packers fans who admitted he got beat on more than a couple of plays, i have a difficult time justifying him as having a very good season.

there being 5 better cornerbacks in the nfc has very little to do with the quality of harris's season.

If he was a top 5 corner in the NFC, I would say that is an excellent season.

i don't think one has any bearing on the other. if there are twenty better corners in the AFC, who cares if he's the second best corner in the nfc? that doesn't really have any specific bearing on the kind of year he's having.

I don't understand that argument at all. Let me put it this way: Name 5 NFC corners who had a better year?