Best QB In NFC North

[Barbecue Bob]

Now that Brett Favre is retired who do you think is the best quarterback in the NFC North?

[RollingMoss]

Did you ask who the best QB in the NFC North is or did you ask what pile of sh*t is the sh*ttiest pile of sh*t in the port-a-potty?

[KCJ58]

[iowatreat54]

neck beard ftw!!!

seriously, it might be Kitna by default, but I'd still take Orton

[regoob2]

Kitna I'd say is the least bad.

[Crazy_Chris]

Obviously it's Jon Kitna by Default.

[neko4]

1 Kitna
2 Rodgers
3 Grossman
4 Jackson
5 Orton

[Crazy_Chris]

Originally Posted by neko4

1 Kitna
2 Rodgers
3 Grossman
4 Jackson
5 Orton

No way is rodgers 2nd, A QB who has NEVER started an NFL game is not going to be that high up the list.

1. Kitna
2.?? I don't think anyone out of the rest has shown enough to truly seperate himself from the flock.

[neko4]

its more of a projection. based off last year(not including Favre), T-Jack is some how Number 2, because Grossman couldnt keep a job.

[BeerBaron]

ky-le or-ton

and his 66% career winning percentage.

though its probably kitna, hes the one eyed man in the land of the blind...but ill put KO as 2nd until either he, or tavaris jackson or maybe rodgers, proves me otherwise

[iowatreat54]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

ky-le or-ton

and his 66% career winning percentage.

though its probably kitna, hes the one eyed man in the land of the blind...but ill put KO as 2nd until either he, or tavaris jackson or maybe rodgers, proves me otherwise

exactly, neck beard has the 2nd most experience and 2nd best stats, plus a neck beard, he's at least #2 (Grossman doesn't count btw)

[TimD]

Right now I want to say Rodgers but we have to wait to see what he does.

[regoob2]

None of these guys deserved to be #2 but by default I'd go with Orton cause of experience. I think Rodgers will have the better season and probably career , but until he plays an entire game I'd go Orton.

[yo123]

Jon Kitna. (puke)

[619]

1. Rodgers
2. Kitna
3. Jackson
4. Grossman

[Crazy_Chris]

Originally Posted by iowatreat54

exactly, neck beard has the 2nd most experience and 2nd best stats, plus a neck beard, he's at least #2 (Grossman doesn't count btw)

Thats not true at all.

[awfullyquiet]

no seriously. how is rodgers pulling #1 or #2. he's not on the list. he hasn't started a game, he did play well against dallas. but that's it

it's still

1) Kitna
2) Orton/Grossman
3) TJax
4) Rodgers.

[iowatreat54]

Originally Posted by Crazy_Chris

Thats not true at all.

who has better stats besides Kitna and excluding sexy rexy...backup vets who will never play don't count

[Crazy_Chris]

Tarvaris Jackson has better stats than Kyle Orton.

[iowatreat54]

Originally Posted by Crazy_Chris

Tarvaris Jackson has better stats than Kyle Orton.

fair enough, he has Orton by 50 yards...I meant career stats in case anyone was wondering...and Kelly Holcomb has the better stats than both...but Orton has more TDs and less INTs, so I consider Orton > Jackson, plus Jackson doesn't have a neck beard

[BeerBaron]

plus orton has won a good deal more games than hes lost than jackson. 66% vs. something under .500 i believe for jackson

and take away the game vs. the bengals in ortons rookie year, and his career stats actually arent all that bad for a young guy

[roidrunner]

its got to be
1. Rodgers
2. kitna
3. nothing
4. Orton
5. grossman
6. Tjack

[yo123]

Originally Posted by roidrunner

its got to be
1. Rodgers
2. kitna
3. nothing
4. Orton
5. grossman
6. Tjack

What the hell has Aaron Rodgers done?

[yo123]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

plus orton has won a good deal more games than hes lost than jackson. 66% vs. something under .500 i believe for jackson

Jackson was 8-4 last year.

[BeerBaron]

i recall a televised scrimmage on the very very young nfl network a few years back where mike sherman had to literally be in the huddle with rodgers to help with play calling.....ha, that was a good laugh

thatll always be my impression of rogers until he proves otherwise