Better year as a sophmore QB...Mccoy or Tebow

[LonghornsLegend]

Which qb has the better year and takes their team further

[MichaelJordanEberle (sabf)]

Originally Posted by LonghornsLegend

Which qb has the better year and takes their team further

I like the new name.

Anyway, I'm inclined to say McCoy on this one, just because it's almost certain he'll be at the very least solid, whereas Tebow is a complete wildcard. He really hasn't proven anything other than his ability to run to one side.

[LonghornsLegend]

Originally Posted by ChrisCybulski

I like the new name.

Anyway, I'm inclined to say McCoy on this one, just because it's almost certain he'll be at the very least solid, whereas Tebow is a complete wildcard. He really hasn't proven anything other than his ability to run to one side.

ya it was a lil outdated lol, preciate it though...


but i thought tebow just only ran the ball because they had leak throwing, i didnt think it was because he couldnt do it...so this next year he will be doing all of it on his own in an offense that suits his style...where as mccoy wont have to start the year slow learning the offense

[BengalsPwn]

Well against west/east carolina (cant remember which one) he came in after the 2nd quarter and threw for 200 yards and 2 tds and rushed for another 2 tds in a 64-7 blowout. He can throw the ball just fine. I thnk the answer to the question is, McCoy has the bigger year stat wise, but Tebow takes his team to a BCS bowl game. Then again im just saying this cause im a gator homer.

[BuddyCHRIST]

west carolina is also an absolutely terrible team. McCoy was outstanding all last year (until he started getting injured) against good competition. Not to mention Charles, Sweed and a bunch of his other WR's are back.

[princefielder28]

I would say Colt McCoy b/c he has more experienced and faces weaker competition

Me being a Gators fan, there will be alittle bias here, but I have to say Tebow.

[DoWnThEfiElD]

Originally Posted by BuddyCHRIST

west carolina is also an absolutely terrible team. McCoy was outstanding all last year (until he started getting injured) against good competition. Not to mention Charles, Sweed and a bunch of his other WR's are back.

I agree. McCoy=somewhat proven

Tebow still has question marks

[Paranoidmoonduck]

McCoy should be really solid once again, so I gotta go with him. I don't think anyone can dispute that Tebow has a butt-ton of potential in Meyers' system, it just depends on how quickly his passing can improve.

[doingthisinsteadofwork]

I'll take Tebow.

[JT Jag]

I think McCoy will have an all-around better year next year because he has the advantage of already having a full year of starting experience.

Tebow may well outpace him before all is said and done, though.

[throwback54milkman]

Mccoy's got better talent around him, and Texas will be rejuvinzed next year (its very hard coming off a national championship, just ask Mack Brown). Ill take Mccoy

[Gribble]

Tebow's probably gonna have Alex Smith like stats this year, plus the running numbers. McCoy just has sophomore slump written all over him.

[draftguru151]

Definitely McCoy. As said Tebow is unproven while McCoy had an great freshman season. Having Sweed coming back really helps.

[KCJ58]

Tim Tebow when it's all said and done will be the greast QB off all time

[4pAc]

McCoy

Originally Posted by throwback54milkman

Mccoy's got better talent around him, and Texas will be rejuvinzed next year (its very hard coming off a national championship, just ask Mack Brown). Ill take Mccoy

Wait, what?

[regoob2]

Probally McCoy.But fot Tebow it depends on how many players return from last years champion team

[draftguru151]

Originally Posted by superfly

Wait, what?

Caldwell and Harvin aren't as good as Sweed, Pittman, Charles, and Texas' OL. Texas' defense is also better.

[sweetness34]

What has Tebow proven in the passing game thus far? He's a beast of a runner but I think I've seen him throw like 2 passes this season at the goaline, one he threw a terrible ball and the other was for a wide open TD.

I think it's going to take some time for this kid.

[geaux tigers]

I dont think McCoy will last a whole season. He just looks really fragile.

[JeffSamardzijaIRISH]

Originally Posted by draftguru151

Caldwell and Harvin aren't as good as Sweed, Pittman, Charles, and Texas' OL. Texas' defense is also better.

Terrance Toliver, Ahmad Paige, Chris Rainey, Jarred Fayson, Deonte Thompson, that's a hell of a lotta talent right there. I think the Gators OL is way better than Texas', and the defense is also a level higher. I see Tim Tebow being the better QB.

[geaux tigers]

Originally Posted by JeffSamardzijaIRISH

Terrance Toliver, Ahmad Paige, Chris Rainey, Jarred Fayson, Deonte Thompson, that's a hell of a lotta talent right there. I think the Gators OL is way better than Texas', and the defense is also a level higher. I see Tim Tebow being the better QB.

Toliver is heading to LSU.

[draftguru151]

Originally Posted by JeffSamardzijaIRISH

Terrance Toliver, Ahmad Paige, Chris Rainey, Jarred Fayson, Deonte Thompson, that's a hell of a lotta talent right there. I think the Gators OL is way better than Texas', and the defense is also a level higher. I see Tim Tebow being the better QB.

Florida's team is all potential. Those guys you listed have a combined 1 catch. Florida's defense is losing 7 starters, and Harvey is the only good one coming back. Texas has one of the best LB corps in college and have Okam coming back up front. They are losing 3 DBs but Texas makes DBs like nothing. Florida's OL is solid, and returning 4 starters helps compares to Texas 2, but the guys at Florida are nothing special, while Tony Hills Jr is one of the best LT in college. Florida's team has potential, but Texas has one of the top WRs and RBs in the country, while Florida has potential greats.

colt.