Originally Posted by luee
Eli has led the Giants to 4 play-offs in a row with 20+ tds and 3000 yds, two division titles and was a SB MVP in only his first full four. HOF start. Certainly among the top 5 QBS in the league
No Eli is not a top 5 QB in this league his disappearence after losing Plax shows that hell I would even go as far as to say he is third in his draft class.
IMO both Romo and Eli are very over rated in their own respects. If Eli was so clutch they would still be in the playoffs althoiugh I would put Eli as a dramatically better QB under pressure (big games big plays ect) than Romo but he isn't Peyton or Brady. Manning had a pro bowl TE as well lest we forget but he was a head case. TO is the #2 reciever on that team next to J-Witt. So saying his WR's amplify his numbers is not totally accurate. Romo has to deal with some of the biggest egos in thet game TO just being the most public. That takes a bit of skill on its own. I don't think Eli deals with egos as well as Romo.
At the end of this string or random thoughts I'd go with
Regular season Romo
Post season Eli
Pre December - Romo
Post December Eli