Alex Smith or Aaron Rodgers??? - Page 3

doingthisinsteadofwork · 03-05-2007, 06:45 PM

I dont think its that fair of a question really.I chose Rodgers cause I liked him more than Alex SMith coming out.But so far he doesnt have the playing time to have proven anything.If anything this should be more of an argument of who the better prospect was coming out.

But Id also like to add this.Without Gore how many games would have SF won this year?

rainbeaukid2 · 03-05-2007, 07:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by doingthisinsteadofwork

I dont think its that fair of a question really.I chose Rodgers cause I liked him more than Alex SMith coming out.But so far he doesnt have the playing time to have proven anything.If anything this should be more of an argument of who the better prospect was coming out.

But Id also like to add this.Without Gore how many games would have SF won this year?

not very many as he was SF's only real weapon this year. i give credit to alex doing as well as he has done this last year with the guys he had. i doubt that that many other young qb's could have done as well with the lack of receiving options and the lack of a consistent oline.