Best NFC East Front Office? - Page 3

21ST · 05-23-2009, 01:28 AM

I pick the redskins just because everyone knows i dont mean it

JHG722 · 05-23-2009, 01:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ricowboy

Giants win period......GM has been there only a few years and they won the SB. Reid and company have been there since 98 and no SB! Giants win!

No, they dont win period, because the consistency of the Eagles has been matched by about 3 other teams in the NFL.

eaglesalltheway · 05-23-2009, 11:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JHG722

No, they dont win period, because the consistency of the Eagles has been matched by about 3 other teams in the NFL.

Though I think the Giants have the edge because of the Superbowl, I agree the gap isn't that big because of the consistency over the last 10 years. There has been no team in the NFC with the Eagles consistency in that span. Now I think in a few years we will be talking about the Giants the same way, but right now I think the Giants have a slight edge over the Eagles due to the Superbowl run.

ricowboy · 05-23-2009, 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JHG722

No, they dont win period, because the consistency of the Eagles has been matched by about 3 other teams in the NFL.

Giants won the SB. Eagles have not. It is very simple. Superbowl victories are what franchises are measured by. If the Eagles win a SB they take the title of best NFC front office. They will have the SB victory and the the best rack record for the last 10 years! The combination of those two pieces give them the title! Don't be so much of a homer that you look past the accomplishments of the Giants front office.

Iamcanadian · 05-26-2009, 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ricowboy

Giants won the SB. Eagles have not. It is very simple. Superbowl victories are what franchises are measured by. If the Eagles win a SB they take the title of best NFC front office. They will have the SB victory and the the best rack record for the last 10 years! The combination of those two pieces give them the title! Don't be so much of a homer that you look past the accomplishments of the Giants front office.

I agree, SB rings measure the be all and end all of a FO. Consistency is nice but believe me championships are nicer.

NY Giants
Phiadelphia Eagles
Tie between 2 interfering owners who have accomplished squat since they took over. Sure Dallas was great with Jimmy Johnson running the show but Jones chased him out of town, won one with Johnson's players then the whole show ground to a halt under Jones's leadership and I think over time it is only going to get worse.
Snyder still thinks he can buy a championship team and with Gibbs gone, he'll probably take the team into last place.