Top 25 WR list

[smittyjs]

His Top 25 WR
1.)Randy Moss

2.)Terrell Owens

3.)Steve Smith

4.)Chad Johnson

5.)Torry Holt

6.)Larry Fitzgerald

7.)Marvin Harrison

8.)Santana Moss

9.)Anquan Boldin

10.)Roy Williams

11.)Donald Driver

12.)Reggie Wayne

13.)Darrell Jackson

14.)Hines Ward

15.)Andre Johnson

16.)Joe Horn

17.)Chris Chambers

18.)Javon Walker

19.)Joey Galloway

20.)Plaxico Burress

21.)Rod Smith

22.)Keyshawn Johnson

23.)Nate Burleson

24.)Deion Branch

25.)Koren Robinson

My top 25 WR list
1. Randy Moss
2. TO
3. Larry Fitzgerald
4. Torry Holt
5. Steve Smith
6. Chad Johnson
7. Marvin Harrison
8. Santana Moss
9. Derrick Mason
10. Anquan Boldin
11. Hines Ward
12. Andre Johnson
13. Rod Smith
14. Joey Galloway
15. Chris Chambers
16. Reggie wayne
17. Joe Horn
18. Plaxico Burress
19. Deion Branch
20. Donald Driver
21. Terry Glenn
22. darrle Jackson
23. Donte' Stallworth
24. Isaac Bruce
25. Javon Walker

[keylime_5]

I like the top 10 like this:

1-Moss
2-Owens
3-Smith
4-Harrison
5-C.Johnson
6-Holt
7-Fitzgerald
8-Ward
9-S.Moss
10-Boldin

Smittyjs- switch Fitzgerald and 85 and it will be better

[duckseason]

Why do you both have Moss #1? Both lists are trash IMO.

Originally Posted by duckseason

Why do you both have Moss #1? Both lists are trash IMO.

then who should be #1?

[smittyjs]

Originally Posted by duckseason

Why do you both have Moss #1? Both lists are trash IMO.

moss might not go over the middle, are be the most repected guy, but come on you knnow he is the best Deep threat and TD wideout in the NFL when he is healthy.

[Packman1957]

Originally Posted by duckseason

Why do you both have Moss #1? Both lists are trash IMO.

Yeah and your the same guy who thinks the Browns are going to pass the Steelers this year. So that's not saying much.

Its ok to make predictions, but please, thats riddicilous.

[duckseason]

Originally Posted by javon favre

then who should be #1?

Somebody who actually puts in some work. There is more to being a great WR than making big plays from time to time.
Moss is possibly the most talented, but he is severely lacking in several key areas. He has the potential to be #1.
I say it's between Johnson and Owens right now. Fitzgerald is right on their tail.

[duckseason]

Originally Posted by Packman1957

Yeah and your the same guy who thinks the Browns are going to pass the Steelers this year. So that's not saying much.

Its ok to make predictions, but please, thats riddicilous.

Saying the Bears would have a year like they did, prior to the '05 season would have sounded ridiculous as well.
Things change very quickly in today's NFL.

[Ho0k Em']

The only thing i don't like about #2 is Steve Smith is too low.

Originally Posted by duckseason

Somebody who actually puts in some work. There is more to being a great WR than making big plays from time to time.
Moss is possibly the most talented, but he is severely lacking in several key areas. He has the potential to be #1.
I say it's between Johnson and Owens right now. Fitzgerald is right on their tail.

How do you know how much work he puts in?

[duckseason]

Originally Posted by javon favre

How do you know how much work he puts in?

Because I've been watching him play since 1998. He doesn't block, he doesn't run crisp routes, and he basically takes every play off if he doesn't think the ball will be coming his way. If he had the work ethic of a guy like Smith/Johnson/Owens/Fitz.....I have little doubt in my mind he would be the best. I'd take Hines Ward over Moss any day.

[Packman1957]

Originally Posted by duckseason

Saying the Bears would have a year like they did, prior to the '05 season would have sounded ridiculous as well.
Things change very quickly in today's NFL.

Ok, the Browns have a QB who I don't think is ready to just go out there and dominate competition. He looks good but all QB's struggle there first except for a select few (Ben Roethlisberger). The Browns just don't have all the peices of the puzzle to be contenders yet.

Your right surprises can happen in the NFL, but this is one I don't agree with at all, especially considering the Steelers IMO are probably one of the best teams going into this season.

[duckseason]

Originally Posted by Packman1957

Ok, the Browns have a QB who I don't think is ready to just go out there and dominate competition. He looks good but all QB's struggle there first except for a select few (Ben Roethlisberger). The Browns just don't have all the peices of the puzzle to be contenders yet.

Your right surprises can happen in the NFL, but this is one I don't agree with at all, especially considering the Steelers IMO are probably one of the best teams going into this season.

So, we disagree. Wow, that's never happend between two football fans before. Let's just wait till december to discuss this further.
We've already been over all the reasons for our opinions on the matter.....don't really feel like re-hashing.
Please keep the quote up at least till then.

[smittyjs]

Originally Posted by duckseason

Somebody who actually puts in some work. There is more to being a great WR than making big plays from time to time.
Moss is possibly the most talented, but he is severely lacking in several key areas. He has the potential to be #1.
I say it's between Johnson and Owens right now. Fitzgerald is right on their tail.

Johnson #1 , he needs to stop talking that he can't back up week in and week out.

[Fogartynyy2789]

You have Andre Johnson @ 12. I wouldn't even consider him Top 20 until he can cut down on the injuries.

[duckseason]

Originally Posted by smittyjs

Johnson #1 , he needs to stop talking that he can't back up week in and week out.

His talk has nothing to do with his play on the field. He generally does back it up. Owens is widely regarded as the top receiver in the league (by players, coaches, analysts, and fans alike), but I think Johnson is a close second.

[jsagan77]

Originally Posted by duckseason

Somebody who actually puts in some work. There is more to being a great WR than making big plays from time to time. Moss is possibly the most talented, but he is severely lacking in several key areas. He has the potential to be #1.
I say it's between Johnson and Owens right now. Fitzgerald is right on their tail.

Not really.. THat is pretty much what he gets paid for.. He is by far the most talented and dangerous reciever in the NFL..

[Jonathan_VIlma]

Coles is better than Branch, Koren Robinson, Burleson and maybe Keyshawn. He just hasn't had a quarterback since 02' Pennington.

[smittyjs]

Originally Posted by Fogartynyy2789

You have Andre Johnson @ 12. I wouldn't even consider him Top 20 until he can cut down on the injuries.

AJ could would rolle his bicth when he played for the titans, and thatb didn't hapeen that much while he was here. This was his first bad year of "Naggin Injuries" so IMO he is a top 12 WR and the texans best player.

[duckseason]

Originally Posted by jsagan77

Not really.. THat is pretty much what he gets paid for.. He is by far the most talented and dangerous reciever in the NFL..

Ummm...yes, really. I agree that he probably has the most talent. I already said that. You really think there's only one aspect to being a WR? He is just as much a liability for his team as he is a dangerous weapon. I wish it weren't true, 'cuz I've always liked Moss.....but it is.

[Packman1957]

By the way I didn't mention its pretty sad that you have to start a thread like this, I really personally don't care what others think. We'll wait to see who is right and who is wrong once the season starts. Asking everyone there opinions doesn't really matter to me, once the season starts we'll find out what predictions look dumb and which ones look correct.

Since I based my predictions off this year, this is about the order I am expecting.

[smittyjs]

It the offseason and this is just for the fun of it, but you where the one who went to name calling for some reason(still don't know why ) and called me out in another thread.

[Packman1957]

Originally Posted by smittyjs

It the offseason and this is just for the fun of it, but you where the one who went to name calling for some reason(still don't know why ) and called me out in another thread.

Well when you put a bunch of lol smilies there at least explain why you think that rather than just put them there, I want a reasoning, I tried to state why I think that. If you don't think so than thats your opinion, but I was trying to back up my reasoning and I do joke around a lot so don't take everything I say seriously. I do it just to see some peoples reaction not to piss them off, I realize calling people out online is for kids, and not for real men.

[Smooth Criminal]

Originally Posted by duckseason

Somebody who actually puts in some work. There is more to being a great WR than making big plays from time to time.
Moss is possibly the most talented, but he is severely lacking in several key areas. He has the potential to be #1.
I say it's between Johnson and Owens right now. Fitzgerald is right on their tail.

After the Browns comment I never thought I'd agree with you on anything, but this I have to. Moss and Owens both arn't #1 in my book. Simply because of they way they are they don't deserve to be the #1. I'd much rather have guys like CJ, Fitz or Harrison who may not have the same level of talent as Moss and Owens, but they are much better to have on a team. Stats arn't everything in the world of football. It says alot that TO could be one of the most talented WRs in history, yet there arn't many teams that had any interest in getting him.

BTW, I hope this helps your self esteem if you get the most votes. I know I would be delighted.