New York Giants Discussion

[Jughead10]

Punters? Rocca was let go by Eagles and some other decent punter I can't think of now was let go. I think we should sign one.

[Giantsfan1080]

I think the Jets let their punter go also. If we stuck with Dodge all of last year I don't see us getting rid of him now.

[Giantsfan1080]

Giants and Shawn Andrews couldn't work out a deal to restructure his contract so he's the next one we let go of.

[Jughead10]

We have to at least bring in someone else and make it an open competition. I can't see how we can reward him with job security.

[Giantsfan1080]

Originally Posted by Jughead10

We have to at least bring in someone else and make it an open competition. I can't see how we can reward him with job security.

If we bring in a veteran punter like Rocca then it's going to be because we cut Dodge. For whatever this FO and coaching staff seems to think he has big time potential though.

[Giantsfan1080]

Re-signed Kevin Boothe to a 2 year deal. It's an all OL day for the G-Men.

[Jughead10]

I'm concerned with safety too. Center, Punter, and Safety. Not in that particular order.

[Giantsfan1080]

Rocky Bernard going to restructure down to league minimum so he'll be around for DT depth.

Garofalo thinks we might be interested in Olin Kreutz or Chris Spencer for C.

I think we'll re-sign Grant and go with the 4 guys there.

[Giantsfan1080]

Geez way to much news all of a sudden. Schefter reporting we are talking to Plax about a return. No clue on how serious.

[LTgiants]

I wouldn't be surprised to see us sign Chris Spencer since he was Eli's center at Ole Miss.

[BaLLiN]

Originally Posted by Giantsfan1080

Geez way to much news all of a sudden. Schefter reporting we are talking to Plax about a return. No clue on how serious.

YESSSSSSSSSSSSS i kept his jersey, please let it happen. I realize that this will probably hurt us in specials, but i think:

Nicks, Smith, Mario, Jernigan, Plax, Barden, Cruz are our 7. Barden has the size, if he wants to make it on the team he needs to play specials. Cruz can return as can Jernigan and both have done some killman duties before (i dont think Hixon should be brought back w/ 1 yr before his contract is up).

what about that DE from Nebraska?

[LTgiants]

Pierre Allen? He ended up signing with the Seahawks not us.

[Jughead10]

We should just sit and let the first wave of free agents go. No team is going to get better by signing these clowns to 6 plus year deals. This is a weak FA class anyway.

[Malaka]

I agree, so long as we lock up our own guys.

From FA all I want is some OL depth, and a lower-tier LB to compete with Sintim/Goff.

[BaLLiN]

Resign Bradshaw or get DWill?

I know they're both very different, and I've grown very very attached to Bradshaw, but DWill has insane vision and agilitly. I love Bradshaw and all but his fumbles ruin us and cutback mentality isn't always productive. I think resign, as do most giants fans on the giants message board, but DWill looks pretty good too..

[LTgiants]

Get Both and reform Earth Wind and Fire lol

No Seriously I would lean towards staying loyal and bring back Bradshaw.

[BaLLiN]

Originally Posted by LTgiants

Get Both and reform Earth Wind and Fire lol

No Seriously I would lean towards staying loyal and bring back Bradshaw.

Just lookin at both of them play over the years I would personally take Williams. Bradshaw is alot choppier, and his running style is the reason for his reoccurring foot and ankle injuries. And I dont know about all of you, but Dwill coming out was such a sexy prospect.

I know Dwill is older, but I think Bradshaw will actually get more money because of his more recent production.

We all know how ward was with the Bucs, our system seems to get average RB's great numbers. Just imagine what a runner with supreme vision and very good agility and speed to take it all the way would do.

[M.O.T.H.]

Cofield signed with the Skins.

[LTgiants]

Originally Posted by M.O.T.H.

Cofield signed with the Skins.

Its Corneilus Griffin all over again lol

[BaLLiN]

Originally Posted by M.O.T.H.

Cofield signed with the Skins.

i kinda got the feeling he'd actually WANT to go to a giant rival. Whatever happened with him i dont know, but i remember when rumors came up that he requested a trade during the season.

[LTgiants]

Originally Posted by BaLLiN

Just lookin at both of them play over the years I would personally take Williams. Bradshaw is alot choppier, and his running style is the reason for his reoccurring foot and ankle injuries. And I dont know about all of you, but Dwill coming out was such a sexy prospect.

I know Dwill is older, but I think Bradshaw will actually get more money because of his more recent production.

We all know how ward was with the Bucs, our system seems to get average RB's great numbers. Just imagine what a runner with supreme vision and very good agility and speed to take it all the way would do.

I like Dwill but I think Bradshaw would be better option since he has been with us and knows our system. Also he has a lot of friends and teammates here.

[Giantsfan1080]

Originally Posted by LTgiants

Its Corneilus Griffin all over again lol

That was my first thought as well. I think Griffin was the better player though. I'm not really interested in bringing in any of the big FA's this year so I'm fine with sitting back and plucking some of the 2nd tier guys. I'd also take Bradshaw back over Williams. Bradshaw will command less money I think.

[Jughead10]

Yeah I think Griffin was a better player too. Offered more in pass rush other than cleaning up other player's pressures.

[Damix]

Well we signed a center, hopefully this works as well as when we signed O'Hara

[BaLLiN]

Originally Posted by Damix

Well we signed a center, hopefully this works as well as when we signed O'Hara

He can also play guard, so if we resign Seubert i think we're good on the interior