Tim Tebow or Matthew Stafford

[robert pancake gallery]

The argument was raised in the other thread that Stafford should have a shot at Tebow, so I decided to continue post whoring and create a second poll to see whether he has a case or not. If you are starting a franchise from scratch who you would you rather have leading your team: Matthew Stafford or Tim Tebow?

My objective analysis for each of the two quarterbacks that will hopefully make your decision easier is below:

Tim Tebow: All he does is win games, sell jerseyz, win national championships, win heismans, praise the lord jesus, make his teammates better, do a really good gator chomp, make good commercials with his mom, not practice premarital sex.

Matthew Stafford: The posterboy for the Detroit Lions, a franchise that loves to lose. He gets injured if you blow on him, he tricked people into thinking Mohammad Massaquoi was worthy of a second round pick in the NFL, he is coached by Jim Schwartz who tells his players to commit unsportsmanlike penalties then gets pissed off when someone shakes his hand too hard.

[CameronCropper]

Matthew Stafford with one arm tied behind his back.

[Brothgar]

This is idiotic and not thread worthy. Tim Tebow is the 8th best QB in his division.

[WinslowBodden]

Originally Posted by broth223

This is idiotic and not thread worthy. Tim Tebow is the 8th best QB in his division.

But the best halfback?

[vidae]

Originally Posted by broth223

This is idiotic and not thread worthy. Tim Tebow is the 8th best QB in his division.

You're being generous today.

[Machiavelli]

Originally Posted by CameronCropper

Matthew Stafford with one arm tied behind his back.

His right one at that even.

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by WinslowBodden

But the best halfback?

Run DMC > Jamaal Charles > Willis > Michael Bush > Taiwan Jones > Tim Tebow.

[WinslowBodden]

Originally Posted by broth223

Run DMC > Jamaal Charles > Willis > Michael Bush > Taiwan Jones > Tim Tebow.

:[ (10 char)

[robert pancake gallery]

Originally Posted by broth223

Run DMC > Jamaal Charles > Willis > Michael Bush > Taiwan Jones > Tim Tebow.

you forgot to include Big Money Thomas Jones.

[prock]

Dumbest thread of all time.

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by robert pancake gallery

you forgot to include Big Money Thomas Jones.

And Mike Tolbert.

[Da-Phins]

Is this guy serious? I mean really? Cmon son!

[WinslowBodden]

What if the Broncos ended up playing the Lions in the Super Bowl and both QB's actually ended up throwing for like 400+ yards.

[Caulibflower]

Originally Posted by robert pancake gallery

My objective analysis for each of the two quarterbacks that will hopefully make your decision easier is below:

Tim Tebow: All he does is win games,

Uh...?

sell jerseyz, win national championships, win heismans, praise the lord jesus, make his teammates better, do a really good gator chomp, make good commercials with his mom, not practice premarital sex.

Well, he does those things. I VOTE TEBOW.

[Razor]

Originally Posted by broth223

This is idiotic and not thread worthy. Tim Tebow is the 8th best QB in his division.

Agreed. And who the **** is Matthew Stanford?

[Brodeur]

Stafford played all 16 games this year and got smoked dozens of times, so that whole getting injured by blowing on him thing doesn't work anymore.

[robert pancake gallery]

the reason i think it is an interesting argument is because statistically a lot of people would be lead to believe that stafford is the superior quarterback, but tebow wins more games and has more intangible value, which ultimately in most peoples' minds makes tebow the obvious candidate

it reminds me of a similar debate i have seen in the past with derek jeter vs barry bands; would you rather have derek jeter, the captain of america's team who leads his team to wins because of his superhuman clutch qualities, or would you rather have this big-headed steroid abuser who disobeys jesus? plus throw in how great jeter plays defense (just look at his gold gloves, case closed), and think about how he has that extra quality that can't really be described, almost as though it was completely fabricated by the media and doesn't actually exist, but it does exist because it has to exist.

i'm not saying stanford is barry bands, but he probably has taken steroids at some point.

[Brodeur]

I'm starting to like this guy.

[DraftSavant]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

I'm starting to like this guy.

Me too. (10)

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by robert pancake gallery

the reason i think it is an interesting argument is because statistically a lot of people would be lead to believe that stafford is the superior quarterback, but tebow wins more games and has more intangible value.

i'm not saying stanford is barry bands, but he probably has taken steroids at some point.

[WMD]

Obviously the answer is Tebow. He loves him some Jaysus.

[Forenci]

Troll thread is trolling?

[robert pancake gallery]

i didn't want to have to do this, but with all the lions fans responses i feel like you are missing just how hard tebow works, so i included a video



if you listen to the trainer during that one exercise he talks about he retracts and holds the dumbbells at the top of his lift, not everyone goes that extra mile.

[MichaelJordanEberle (sabf)]

Examining their NFL careers, they're pretty even. Both have one playoff appearance, but it's coming this weekend so we can't compare. Stafford had injury troubles earlier in his career, so we'll have to count that against him. Slight edge Tebow.

In college, Tebow has 2 NCs to Stafford's zero. Tebow has one Heisman and was invited to NY 3 times. Stafford has zero trophies and AFAIK was never invited to NY for the ceremony. So college is a clear point for Tebow.

So I think it's pretty clear that Tebow is the better choice here. I like Stafford a lot, but he has a way to go before he can be called better than Tebow.

[Crazy_Chris]

http://www.draftcountdown.com/forum/...earchid=840296

RPG has been Tebow trolling for a while now. For his excellence in doing such I think he has legitly earned a golden troll award... Congrats!