What teams have the worst QB? Worst back-up QB?

[Brothgar]

Originally Posted by XxXdragonXxX

It feels really dumb arguing about backup qbs, but...

I fail to see how Henne is better than Moore. Moore easily outplayed Henne last season. He also looked pretty good a few years ago in Carolina. Henne has never looked good. Honestly I was surprised that the Dolphins tried so hard to replace Moore.

Henne only played what a whopping three and a half games last season? Matt Moore played well in stretches but so did Henne. Lets not forget that Henne was the starter that season as well.

[fenikz]

Originally Posted by Shane P. Hallam

Let's rank the back-up QBs:



32. St. Louis Rams – Kellen Clemens
31. Green Bay Packers – Graham Harrell
30. New Orleans Saints – Chase Daniel
29. Carolina Panthers – Derek Anderson
28. Cincinnati Bengals – Bruce Gradkowski
27. Denver Broncos – Caleb Hanie
26. San Diego Chargers – Charlie Whitehurst
25. Philadelphia Eagles – Mike Kafka
24. Oakland Raiders – Matt Leinart
23. Buffalo Bills – Vince Young
22. Jacksonville Jaguars – Chad Henne
21. Indianapolis Colts – Drew Stanton
20. New York Giants – David Carr
19. Kansas City Chiefs – Brady Quinn
18. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Dan Orlovsky
17. Washington Redskins – Rex Grossman
16. Baltimore Ravens – Tyrod Taylor
15. Pittsburgh Steelers – Charlie Batch
14. Minnesota Vikings – Rosenfels/Webb
13. Miami Dolphins – David Garrard/Tannehill
12. Atlanta Falcons – Chris Redman
11. Cleveland Browns – Colt McCoy
10. Arizona Cardinals – John Skelton
9. Seattle Seahawks – Tarvaris Jackson/Russell Wilson
8. San Francisco 49ers – Josh Johnson
7. New York Jets – Tim Tebow
6. Chicago Bears – Jason Campbell
5. New England Patriots – Brian Hoyer
4. Houston Texans – TJ Yates
3. Detroit Lions – Shaun Hill
2. Dallas Cowboys – Kyle Orton
1. Tennessee Titans – Matt Hasselbeck/Jake Locker


This was tougher than I thought. I may have guys like Tyrod Taylor (unproven,) or Charlie Batch (reliable but old,) too high while guys like Bruce Gradkowski who has struggled when he came in, may be too low because he can manage games. I wonder if Brees or Rodgers goes down this year what would happen to GB or NO

2 1sts to AZ for Skelton!