Community Mafia Game Thread- Day Seven- Pg. 62- GREENDALE WINS! - Page 51

vidae · 07-20-2012, 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

I don't ever recall one in a game I was in that's why I wasn't sure if we have or not. That being said, typically they are lynchers for power roles, like role cop.

The only instance that immediately comes to mind is a game where there were two lynchers and their targets were each other.

Dr. Gonzo · 07-20-2012, 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by njx9

i did that once, after explaining my reasoning for my vote clearly.

intentional illiteracy is more mafia than the 5th vote for a player with an extremely questionable role claim.

Fair enough. You do realize thought that I could have claimed any number of things if I were mafia though right? It would not have been that hard and I certainly would not claim a role that is often mafia. I am not new to these games. I told the truth despite knowing that it would seem suspicious. I did the same in the OC game. With us not being able to trust Vidae and with a protector and tracker down I think that TH and I are even more important. Me having a lyncher makes sense to balance out the power of my role a bit.

Grizzlegom · 07-20-2012, 01:02 PM

In all seriousness though, if Caddy really is a lyncher for you, he probably came when he got his role.

Dr. Gonzo · 07-20-2012, 01:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vidae

The only instance that immediately comes to mind is a game where there were two lynchers and their targets were each other.

I think that was the last time. It was me and ATL. Before that though Woot was a lyncher and I have seen it a couple other times. Much like a good role cop though it's been a while.

vidae · 07-20-2012, 01:02 PM

This is not the first time you've claimed to have a lyncher either. It feels like a reach every time you claim it.

Dr. Gonzo · 07-20-2012, 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

In all seriousness though, if Caddy really is a lyncher for you, he probably came when he got his role.

He actually did not need to play any different and with me lynched he joins the winners circle. He must be so happy right now.

SuperMcGee · 07-20-2012, 01:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

First time mods always pimp out the town, its a fact (no offense Cigaro, I did it in the Psych game). For that reason I don't buy into any "the town is too OP with power roles" argument. In addition, if the town has a role cop, it makes sense that there would be a lyncher. Anyone who has modded before and has read through the wiki would know that. We haven't seen a lyncher in a long time (or ever?) so maybe I'm just spitballing here. I don't know a single thing about Community but from what I've gathered, it doesn't seem like a lyncher would be off for the theme.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

I don't ever recall one in a game I was in that's why I wasn't sure if we have or not. That being said, typically they are lynchers for power roles, like role cop.

I agree that lyncher was possible in this game. I certainly thought it was during the vidae-Bulldogs scenario. I used to think the target would be a non-power role, but I've seen both. Not sure if that relates to what's going on now, I'm not getting caught up in lyncher talk, this time.

Quote:

Originally Posted by njx9

i did that once, after explaining my reasoning for my vote clearly.

intentional illiteracy is more mafia than the 5th vote for a player with an extremely questionable role claim.

A 5th vote for any player is more serial killer.

Dr. Gonzo · 07-20-2012, 01:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vidae

This is not the first time you've claimed to have a lyncher either. It feels like a reach every time you claim it.

You are right. I have been wrong about it before. People go hard after me without evidence every single game so ya kind of a boy who cried wolf thing. Without saying too much it does make sense this time though. I actually didn't even think about it until Grizz mentioned it since I have been wrong about having a lyncher so often.

njx9 · 07-20-2012, 01:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

Fair enough. You do realize thought that I could have claimed any number of things if I were mafia though right? It would not have been that hard and I certainly would not claim a role that is often mafia. I am not new to these games. I told the truth despite knowing that it would seem suspicious. I did the same in the OC game. With us not being able to trust Vidae and with a protector and tracker down I think that TH and I are even more important. Me having a lyncher makes sense to balance out the power of my role a bit.

i don't think you're stupid. but i also assume you believe no one thinks you're stupid. aside from LOTR, i've never seen rolecop as a good role, and even in LOTR, there was no lyncher role. i'm willing to wait for TH, but as the 5th vote, i'm unsure why i'm being called out for not waiting. might as well call out caddy and tackle (though, i guess, it seems like you're subtly calling out caddy as the lyncher?).

essentially, this feels like the kind of move i've seen the mafia make, when i've been mafia, to try to swing a false investigator. i believe i actually saw you make a similar move in LOTR, though i could be completely confusing you with Renji (apologies if i am).

SuperPacker · 07-20-2012, 01:08 PM

Can someone explain why Gonzo is still alive. It's pretty clear he is evil.

I know we're waiting for TH, but we could be waiting for hours.

njx9 · 07-20-2012, 01:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperMcgee

A 5th vote for any player is more serial killer.

that's ridiculous.

so i should like, make sure and vote 3rd in the future? is that a town vote?

Dr. Gonzo · 07-20-2012, 01:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

Can someone explain why Gonzo is still alive. It's pretty clear he is evil.

I know we're waiting for TH, but we could be waiting for hours.

Pushing for a quick lynch. Makes sense after I cleared you I suppose you ******* GF.

vidae · 07-20-2012, 01:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

Can someone explain why Gonzo is still alive. It's pretty clear he is evil.

I know we're waiting for TH, but we could be waiting for hours.

I don't like this post. And you're nuts if you think you're somehow above suspicion to the rest of us.

vidae · 07-20-2012, 01:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by njx9

that's ridiculous.

so i should like, make sure and vote 3rd in the future? is that a town vote?

1-3 = town vote, 4-5 = serial killer, anything after 5 = Mafia. Duh.

Dr. Gonzo · 07-20-2012, 01:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by njx9

i don't think you're stupid. but i also assume you believe no one thinks you're stupid. aside from LOTR, i've never seen rolecop as a good role, and even in LOTR, there was no lyncher role. i'm willing to wait for TH, but as the 5th vote, i'm unsure why i'm being called out for not waiting. might as well call out caddy and tackle (though, i guess, it seems like you're subtly calling out caddy as the lyncher?).

essentially, this feels like the kind of move i've seen the mafia make, when i've been mafia, to try to swing a false investigator. i believe i actually saw you make a similar move in LOTR, though i could be completely confusing you with Renji (apologies if i am).

In LOTR I sacrificed BD and I did claim investigator (not role cop though since that is never believed haha). Both BD and I were evil. I mean you can say I think that nobody thinks I am stupid but it is clear there are people that do. I figured truth was the best defence but this won't have been the first time I was wrong about that.

SuperPacker · 07-20-2012, 01:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vidae

I don't like this post. And you're nuts if you think you're somehow above suspicion to the rest of us.

Why would I think that? And i'm just wondering what we're wanting to hear from TH.

njx9 · 07-20-2012, 01:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vidae

1-3 = town vote, 4-5 = serial killer, anything after 5 = Mafia. Duh.

but you forgot, if you vote, you're mafia. if you don't vote, you're mafia. if you voted for someone else, you're mafia.

it's mafia all the way down.

Grizzlegom · 07-20-2012, 01:13 PM

Just in case two more bandwagoners come along and I die tonight, I just wanted to throw this out there. I know its been suggested that vidae might actually be evil and that the mafia threw bulldogs under the bus to get in bed with the town. I'm not saying that's definitely the case but I do want to point out that this would not be uncharted territory for bulldogs. In two games where I had intimate knowledge of his actions (Saiyan Saga and Zombie Apocalypse), Bulldogs did just that. In the Saiyan saga game he volunteered to be a scapegoat because he was a hunter and was happy to sacrifice himself for his team. In the zombie game, we were pretty sure vidae and IBC were ERO so we made the decision to have bulldogs go at them hard, knowing it would probably condemn him but we would come out ahead because that was two more ERO lynches and we could potentially turn a couple more zombies to the cause. Now I'm not saying this was definitely the case here but I'm just hoping people aren't completely closing this thought process out. And before Caddy comes back and says its ******** to give up the godfather of all people, bulldogs didn't have a secondary role so losing the godfather is probably secondary to losing a goon in that a tailor, framer, shotted strongman, roleblocker, etc tends to be much more valuable.

Now that my crazy theory is out there, back to the task at hand.

SuperMcGee · 07-20-2012, 01:15 PM

vid, do you have any thoughts on this? Could be pointless or even misdirecting, but I'm still curious. You're supposedly good and knowledgeable about the source. Does it make sense to you, in general? Or does it stand out in some way?

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperMcgee

In time, Caddy.

What I'm curious about right now is sbh's death description: The "long rod or something similar." Wondering who that might imply. I think it was interesting that most of Drew's posts were suspecting who the evil characters could be and he ended up being the first target for this killer.

Grizzlegom · 07-20-2012, 01:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by njx9

that's ridiculous.

so i should like, make sure and vote 3rd in the future? is that a town vote?

As I said before, it was the manner in which you voted. I get that you are suspicious of both of them but when multiple town people are calling to slow down the train and wait for more information, you then come in and vote. That's what I found suspicious.

vidae · 07-20-2012, 01:15 PM

If you guys want to lynch me go for it, but there was no "plan" and I wasn't in on anything with Bulldogs.

vidae · 07-20-2012, 01:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperMcgee

vid, do you have any thoughts on this? Could be pointless or even misdirecting, but I'm still curious. You're supposedly good and knowledgeable about the source. Does it make sense to you, in general? Or does it stand out in some way?

I'm at a loss with this one, but if I had to pick I think that it could either be Troys Grandma (which would be lol worthy if that were a role) or Senor Chang. I really don't know though.

SuperPacker · 07-20-2012, 01:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vidae

I'm at a loss with this one, but if I had to pick I think that it could either be Troys Grandma (which would be lol worthy if that were a role) or Senor Chang. I really don't know though.

I think it might be Troy's Grandma as well. She could easily be the serial killer, because she hates everyone and she uses rods/sticks to hit people.

FlyingElvis · 07-20-2012, 01:26 PM

So . . . I can't vote now without being mafia, is that what I'm reading?

It's already been nearly 12 hours since the "Let's wait to hear from TH" stuff began.

njx9 · 07-20-2012, 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

As I said before, it was the manner in which you voted. I get that you are suspicious of both of them but when multiple town people are calling to slow down the train and wait for more information, you then come in and vote. That's what I found suspicious.

*shrug* that's fine.

unvote gonzo

let me know when we have enough information.