Old West Side-Game Thread - Rufus Wins!!

[vidae]

Originally Posted by Mrs. Grizz

Are we sure it's not one of those random 'this is a joke' votes? Does McGee usually play like that, or is he saying **** it and just trying to get the game over with?

McGee doesn't usually joke vote like that, and he said it was completely random and that's it. Very un-McGee like in previous games.

[RufusMcDaniel]

Originally Posted by Mrs. Grizz

Are we sure it's not one of those random 'this is a joke' votes? Does McGee usually play like that, or is he saying **** it and just trying to get the game over with?

this is definitely a different mcgee than most games

[CJSchneider]

But does that make him evil? One could interpret it as someone who is too playful to be a GF.

[BeerBaron]

Updated Vote Count:

Cain (2) - Renji, ATL
Renji (1) - McGee
McGee (1) - vidae

With 8 alive, 5 are needed for majority.

[Mrs. Grizz]

You know, I've been doing some thinking as I stand here making grilled cheese. I've been suspicious of Vidae from the start, and if I recall correctly, so was a lot of other people. However, I was curious as I was thinking about how quickly he and Rufus jumped on the 'hey, I agree with you' bandwagon. And looking back, at least Vidae has done the same thing every time that I've said I'm suspicious of someone, and it's helped lead towards them getting lynched, and they've been good guys each time. Now it seems to me that Vidae is evil, and that he's hiding his/the mafia's actions behind the inexperience that I have, and passing it off as 'oh well, she's new,' but it does seem to me that he's been helping encourage the suspicions that I have, and the more that I read back and think about it, the more shady this seems. I think it's time to start looking at Vidae again, town.

Vote: Vidae

[vidae]

Look at me for "jumping" on a lynch train, but not the person starting the train each time? And it doesn't take two people to lynch someone, it takes more, but I'm the most suspicious?

And not once have I said "oh well she's new" or anything of the sort.

Interesting theory. You're wrong, but it's still interesting.

[BeerBaron]

Updated Vote Count:

Cain (2) - Renji, ATL
Renji (1) - McGee
McGee (1) - vidae
vidae (1) - Mrs. Grizz

With 8 alive, 5 are needed for majority.

Getting ready to go see the god damn Batman. Someone close the thread if we hit majority.

[ImBrotherCain]

I think I am down to CJ or Renji for my vote today.

CJ has tried to hard to defend me... That is something I would do if I was evil and CJ is a meticulous, devious old bastard easily something I would see him do.

Renji has not been Renji. Slow playing is far from his style and he just seems to be coasting.

Of the two I think Renji (GOW) has a higher potential to be evil but CJ is almost too smart, too thorough for me to just overlook him.

[ATLDirtyBirds]

You're all evil. Everyone but me.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by ATLDirtyBirds

You're all evil. Everyone but me.

You fraudin brah.

[Gay Ork Wang]

i have been playing these slow games because people dont play serious anymore. people joke vote and all that stuff. id rather just come in now, voice my concerns, and once we actually have a discussion going, im in it. otherwise it just generate 23 pages of nothing.

also funny how i suddenly am suspicious after i voted Cain.

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by *** Ork Wang

i have been playing these slow games because people dont play serious anymore. people joke vote and all that stuff. id rather just come in now, voice my concerns, and once we actually have a discussion going, im in it. otherwise it just generate 23 pages of nothing.

also funny how i suddenly am suspicious after i voted Cain.

I called you suspicious yesterday brah.

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

I was battling two thoughts.

The frame was in an attempt to try and take me down and the people who should be active at this time and would probably do such a thing at this time would be:
CJ, Vidae, ATL, Renji and possibly JR.

Just for good measure.

[SuperMcGee]

Originally Posted by RufusMcDaniel

this is definitely a different mcgee than most games

I wouldn't disagree, for the most part. I don't have much experience with small games. Usually by the time it's down to 8 people, I know who I think is evil. So do others and the thread actually moves. Mrs. Grizz asked if I'm just trying to get the game over with. I would not say that, but I would like it to get moving, hence some randomness and loose voting.

The Renji vote was complete randomness. I forgot he was in the game. Maybe it was a sign. He's part of a muddled group of people I would vote for, but pretty much everyone is.

And I was never even really suspicious of you, Rufus. Gosh.

[ATLDirtyBirds]

Prepare to die.

[vidae]

Originally Posted by SuperMcgee

I wouldn't disagree, for the most part. I don't have much experience with small games. Usually by the time it's down to 8 people, I know who I think is evil. So do others and the thread actually moves. Mrs. Grizz asked if I'm just trying to get the game over with. I would not say that, but I would like it to get moving, hence some randomness and loose voting.

The Renji vote was complete randomness. I forgot he was in the game. Maybe it was a sign. He's part of a muddled group of people I would vote for, but pretty much everyone is.

And I was never even really suspicious of you, Rufus. Gosh.

That explains a lot actually, and I can't say I disagree with your assessment of small games.

unvote : McGee

For now. I'm still not entirely sure who to vote for here.

[Grizzlegom]

Updated Vote Count:

Cain (2) - Renji, ATL
Renji (1) - McGee
vidae (1) - Mrs. Grizz

With 8 alive, 5 are needed for majority.

[CJSchneider]

Cain, I have no qualms with you being suspicious of me, but know that I won't cast a vote for you as my logic and gut feeling both tell me you are not evil at this point.

I too was hoping for assistance from random events and to be honest, any vote I would cast would only be to prolong my own life. I would like to continue behind Mrs. G., but thanks to the poisonous hiss of a grilled cheese sandwich, even that garners suspicion.
I can only offer that which I already have.

[ATLDirtyBirds]

Everyone role reveal right now.

[Gay Ork Wang]

Originally Posted by ATLDirtyBirds

Everyone role reveal right now.

You start!

im going to bed btw

[SuperMcGee]

CJ's play is a little odd, but I bought the way he claimed townie. Not sure if I can say the same about Mrs. Grizz. The three people currently with votes could all be evil. I don't intend on voting for Rufus, and I'm pretty sure this game is going to end with a duel between me and ATL. I'll leave my vote on Renji, for now, but I could switch it to Cain or the missus.

[ImBrotherCain]

I am going Renji

Vote: Renji

[Grizzlegom]

Updated Vote Count:

Cain (2) - Renji, ATL
Renji (2) - McGee, Cain
vidae (1) - Mrs. Grizz

With 8 alive, 5 are needed for majority.

[CJSchneider]

My inclination now is to either vote for vidae or renji, but only because I had considered following Mrs. G, and I feel Cain is good. I have nothing against either of them, so I am admittedly hung up at present. As hasty decisions often yield poor ones, I would prefer to think about this a bit longer.

[vidae]

I'm in the same boat. I don't like how a few people have played, but I can't say as I think anyone in particular is evil. I'm sort of stumped.