Jake Plummer vs. Jay Cutler

Who would you rather builid a team around?

[Shane P. Hallam]

Obviously, you build around Cutler. If I have a near playoff team? I'd rather have Plummer.


Also, you NEED to downsize your avatar. It should be 100X100 at most.

[Ravens1991]

Cutler, Plummer is like 31

but plummer has expirence that cutler doesnt have

[Ravens1991]

ya but when you say build a team around I think you mean a long term project, a win later situation, I think that will take about 3-5 yeras to create, I wouldn't want a QB past his prime.

Originally Posted by broncosfan144

but plummer has expirence that cutler doesnt have

ya but you said Who would you rather builid a team around?
you dont build ya team around buy someone whos 10yr+
some times you do thou

[slightlyaraiderfan]

Where's the option for "Neither, Broncos blow."

[Splat]

Jay Cutler has looked like crap so far.

[Staubach12]

I'd take Cutler.

[diabsoule]

Is there really a choice here? Plummer is past his prime and Cutler is young and has a chance to be a good QB.

[Jonathan_VIlma]

Cutler is like a recently drafted version of Plummer. He doesn't know how to win, yet has good measureables.

[Splat]

Jay Cutler = Kyle Boller

[bigbluedefense]

Originally Posted by Jonathan_VIlma

Cutler is like a recently drafted version of Plummer. He doesn't know how to win, yet has good measureables.

Good observation.

A better question would be, who do you build around, Leinart or Cutler. There, you have 2 young up and comers, one with intangibles and a winning background but has limitations physically, the other has all the physical gifts but makes mental errors, bad mechanics and doesn't win. That would be a good question.

Me personally, I favor East Coast/run the ball/vertical pass game offense, so I'd take Cutler. If I had Leinart, id implement a west coast offense, he couldn't be a vertical passer.

[Jonathan_VIlma]

Originally Posted by bigbluedefense

Good observation.

A better question would be, who do you build around, Leinart or Cutler. There, you have 2 young up and comers, one with intangibles and a winning background but has limitations physically, the other has all the physical gifts but makes mental errors, bad mechanics and doesn't win. That would be a good question.

Me personally, I favor East Coast/run the ball/vertical pass game offense, so I'd take Cutler. If I had Leinart, id implement a west coast offense, he couldn't be a vertical passer.

It's not like Leinart can't throw the deep ball. But he does loft the ball at times. Shouldn't be a problem with Anquan Boldin and Larry Fitzgerald.

[Ravens1991]

Originally Posted by Splat420

Jay Cutler = Kyle Boller

When I read Scotts scouting report he sounded like the Kyle Boller with Intangibles, ya he can throw the ball far, he has good size and can run fast but decision making is bad.










This is what I read from Scotts scouting report, don't flip out on me saying "you haven't seen a game of his shut up, he had no talent around him he will lead the Bronco's to the superbowl and have several all-pro seasons"

[The Unseen]

I favor East Coast/run the ball/vertical pass game offense

Do you say that because it's opposed to the West? Or do you have a reason?

The West Coast's opposite is the Air Coryell, which is from San Diego (the original WCO).

[bearfan]

Definantly Cutler. Plumber like said is past his prime, and you dont build a team around a QB that will only be in the league for at least 3 years.

Cutler = Farve

Who wouldnt want to build around him (either one)? Cutler has the intangibles to be a good QB in the NFL.

[bigbluedefense]

Originally Posted by The Unseen

Do you say that because it's opposed to the West? Or do you have a reason?

The West Coast's opposite is the Air Coryell, which is from San Diego (the original WCO).

I thought (I could be wrong) that classic East Coast offense was built around running the ball like heck, and coupling that with PA vertical passes ala Pittsburgh. Lombardi set that tone with the Giants when he was our offensive coordinator, im sure it was around far before him. But being that football started in college waaay back in the day and the east coast had more colleges, and back then all they did was run, i always thought that the old school offense was simply known as East coast offense, and west coast offense being designed as a ying to east coast's yang. I could be wrong.

[President]

Cutler, Plummer is garbage.

Jake Plummer duh, why wouldnt you want a 32 year old QB who cant win big games for your franchise?

[jackalope]

you don't build a team around a QB over 30.

[ninerfan]

I took Cutler but gee the snake is a bloody good QB as well. Why are we all writing him off?

[Shiver]

Jake Plummer is always disrespected, it's insanity.

[Staubach12]

Cutler had one of the worst supporting casts in college football. He had the worst line, so he had a very short time to throw. He also had bad WRs, so he had to put the ball in small windows. Isn't that what the NFL is all about? Less time and smaller windows. He'll be fine.

[smittyjs]

Jay Cutler future MVP