Which game scenerio would you rather have?

[Smokey Joe]

Okay, lets say that 2K bought the rights to NFL games and that EA bought the rights for the MLB Games. There would still be MVP Baseball and 2k Football.

So, my question is, would you rather have what it is in like the scenerio I just mentioned, or how it is in real life? So, basically I am asking, which two games would you rather be able to get, MVP Baseball and NFL 2K or MLB 2K and Madden Football.

[Smokey Joe]

I went with MVP and NFL 2K because MVP Baseball was a great baseball game, and NFL 2K wasn't all that bad (even though I love Madden).

MLB 2K is just plain awful.

[DHVF]

I went with Madden and MLB2K as I love Madden and really liked MLB2K6. I was never a fan of NFL2K and although I loved MVP more than any other baseball game out there, I didn't like it all that much more than MLB2K.

[critesy]

i said madden because i dont play baseball

[TheChampIsHere]

madden is the only game that matters

[Paranoidmoonduck]

I haven't played the next gen Madden's, but I haven't been impressed with the current gen ones for three versions now. The NCAA team has produced vastly better games recently than the Madden one.

MVP was about as fun as sports games get, and the staff put in fantastic details (Safeco Field roof closing during rain). Also, it looked amazing. I never had a problem with 2K Football, and I always felt that they improved more year to year than Madden (although the product was a bit rougher around the edges).

Basically, the differences between Madden and 2K Football are negligible enough that the differences between MVP and 2K Baseball (which sucks astounding amounts of ass) decide this for me.

[Canadian_kid16]

I would have to say MVP and Madden 2K cause IMO MVP was one of the greatest sports games made...period

[draftguru151]

That's tough and I think MVP and 2K would put up a fight but I would have to go with madden.

[scoopdawg]

the only 2k game i would get is basketball

[SeanTaylorRIP]

I don't play baseball games but I think that NFL I think it was 2k4 or 5 with TO on the cover was better than Madden. Price aside(was $20 on release date) that game was just IMO better and much cleaner than Madden.

[jets future]

nfl 2k and mvp baseball because, nfl 2k5 was so much better than madden 05, and the price was better, ea was scared that nfl 2k series was getting more popular than madden so they bought the rights and mvp base balll is better than the mlb 2k series

Originally Posted by scoopdawg

the only 2k game i would get is basketball

yea nba 2k6 is the best basketball game on the market. id go with mlb 2k6 and madden

[GB12]

I go with MLB06.

[Shiver]

I never liked NFL 2k, it just didn't feel right.

[HChu]

Originally Posted by ghettosermon

I don't play baseball games but I think that NFL I think it was 2k4 or 5 with TO on the cover was better than Madden. Price aside(was $20 on release date) that game was just IMO better and much cleaner than Madden.

Quoted for emphasis

[JETS5128]

Originally Posted by Shiver

I never liked NFL 2k, it just didn't feel right.

I agree, it had all the features, gang tackling, double team blocks etc. But when u played it it just felt sluggish and akward

[draftguru151]

Originally Posted by cardsalltheway

yea nba 2k6 is the best basketball game on the market. id go with mlb 2k6 and madden

Yea I still get 2k6 over live, the game play is much better.

[VoteLynnSwan]

I chose madden and 2K6, but only because MLB 06 The Show was pretty good, and 2K6 Football isn't even comparable to Madden.