In 2008, Scott Wright began his “Dream Draft” Series, one of my favorites at Draft Countdown. As draftniks, all of us feel like we can do a better job picking players than most real GMs, so the Dream Draft puts it to the test. I will be continuing his series and using the team he drafted from 2008-2019 (active players listed at the bottom of this post) and mine from 2020-2021. Here are the guidelines for the challenge:
- I will get one selection in the middle of every round of the draft.
- In each round, I can only select a prospect who actually went in that frame.
- I can’t take anyone who was selected before my mid-round slot.
- I can’t choose more than one prospect at each position.
- I will also be allowed to sign one undrafted free agent.
- I will not be selecting for any particular offensive or defensive scheme.
See the 2021 article here
Tyler Linderbaum, C, Iowa
One of the most fun players to watch in his final season, Linderbaum was an absolute monster for the Hawkeyes. He created holes where their were none and always brought 110%. His small size and short arms knocked him off certain draft boards, but it was the always savvy Baltimore Ravens who snatched up the value on Linderbaum. The Ravens are favored to make the playoffs this year partially due to a great draft. Two years in a row selecting a Raven is interesting, but Linderbaum should have been drafted higher. He can even kick over to Guard for the team and complete the offensive line.
Actual: Baltimore Ravens (#25 Overall)
George Pickens, WR, Georgia
Pickens had an illustrious career at Georgia (who are still +350 to win the national championship) stepping in as their top WR from Day One. He fell in the draft due to an ACL injury in his final season, as well as some attitude concerns. What isn’t a concern is his talent. Pickens catch radius and body control are exceptional and he perfectly fits the offense the Steelers run. Add in Kevin Colbert has been the absolute king of picking WRs and chose Pickens (along with teammate Calvin Austin) in his final draft in charge, and this is a slam dunk pick.
Actual: Pittsburgh Steelers (#52 Overall)
Matt Corral, QB, Mississippi
Getting a successful QB in the Dream Draft is beyond difficult, so taking a chance on a Day 2 QB is usually the best bet. Corral was my QB1 going into the draft due to his quick release, athleticism, and toughness. With some looming intangibles and readiness questions, he is a project for the Panthers who also brought in Baker Mayfield. This selection was made before Corral’s Lisfranc injury, but it was likely to be a redshirt year anyway. Despite the problems, Corral has the make-up of a future NFL starter if he gets a chance to prove it.
Actual: Carolina Panthers (#94 Overall)
Isaiah Likely, TE, Coastal Carolina
One of Brian’s favorite players in this draft, Likely had one of the biggest discrepencies between athleticism on film and in his workouts. Looking fast and agile consistently in college, Likely’s poor testing knocked him into Day 3 as a potential steal for the Ravens (once again). A pass catcher who is willing to throw blocks, Likely has some Mark Andrews to him. Though it will take some time, Likely will be a solid pass catching NFL TE.
Actual: Baltimore Ravens (#139 Overall)
Dominique Robinson, EDGE, Miami (OH)
Robinson’s dominant performance against Bowling Green has always stuck in my mind as his athleticism blew off the charts of the MAC. Robinson came to the Redhawks as a WR and transitioned to being a Defensive End going into his Junior season. Even with only two years at the position, Robinson flashed NFL potential and is in a situation where he can get some early work.
Actual: Chicago Bears (#174 Overall)
Tariq Castro-Fields, CB, Penn State
I was irrational high on Castro-Fields who I rated as an early 4th round pick. After falling to the end of the 6th round, Castro-Fields got picked up by a 49ers squad who needs defensive back help. Though he isn’t an insane athlete like many Nittany Lions, Castro-Fields has that CB/S tweener ability to make good plays on the football. A sound tackler with good instincts, the versatility means making a football team. Maybe Castro-Field ends up as a special teamer at best, but for a 6th round picks, sticking around the NFL awhile is a win.
Actual: San Francisco 49ers (#221 Overall)
Isaih Pacheco, RB, Rutgers
Pacheco was a surprise early declare whose game was based on pure speed at Rutgers. But, with a below average offensive line and facing some tough opponents, Pacheco only shined in a handful of games. This led to a big fall to the 7th round, but he is an ideal fit for Andy Reid’s offense with good one cut ability. Could Pacheco be a surprise starter at RB in a few years? It is very possible.
Actual: Kansas City Chiefs (#251 Overall)
Undrafted Free Agent
Sterling Weatherford, S, Miami (OH)
Another Redhawk makes the team with the big, fast Weatherford. He plays stiff, but the size, speed, hitting combination makes Weatherford a perfect fit for the Colts special teams unit. Though Weatherford struggled with his stiffness and coverage ability, the coverage unit is ideal for him. Look for Weatherford to stick around the NFL and potentially find his way on defense in a pinch.
Actual: Indianapolis Colts
Active Dream Draft Team Members
QB: Matt Corral (’22) Jarrett Stidham (‘19) DeShone Kizer (‘17) Teddy Bridgewater (‘14)
RB: Isaih Pacheco (’22) Jermar Jefferson (‘21) J.K. Dobbins (‘20) Derrius Guice (‘18) Devontae Booker (‘16) Buck Allen (‘15)
WR: George Pickens (’22) Rashod Bateman (‘21) CeeDee Lamb (‘20) Kelvin Harmon (‘19) Equanimeous St. Brown (‘18) Malachi Dupre (‘17) Braxton Miller (‘16) Dez Bryant (‘10) Desean Jackson (‘08)
TE: Isaiah Likely (’22) Irv Smith Jr. (‘19) O.J. Howard (‘17) Nick Boyle (‘15) Jared Cook (‘09)
OT: Samuel Cosmi (‘21) Orlando Brown (‘18) Zach Banner (‘17) Jason Spriggs (‘16) Jordan Mills (‘13)
G: Trey Smith (‘21) Kyle Hinton (‘20) Joshua Miles (‘19) La’el Collins (‘15) Laurent Duvernay-Tardiff (‘14)
C: Tyler Linderbaum (’22) Quinn Meinerz (‘21) Will Clapp (‘18)
EDGE: Dominique Robinson (’22) Rashad Weaver (‘21) James Lynch (‘20) Josh Sweat (‘18) Bud Dupree (‘15) Randy Gregory (‘15)
DL: Jeffery Simmons (‘19) Jaylon Ferguson (‘19) Davon Gaudchaux (‘17) Robert Nkemdiche (‘16) Tyler Matakevich (‘16) Carl Davis (‘15)
LB: K.J. Britt (‘21) Justin Strnad (‘20) D’Andre Walker (‘19) Terrill Hanks (‘19) Jeff Holland (‘18) Harvey Langi (‘17) Dadi Nicolas (‘16) Jordan Tripp (‘14) Christian Jones (‘14) Lavonte David (‘12) Vontaze Burfict (‘12)
CB: Tariq Castro-Fields (’22) Shakur Brown (‘21) Cameron Dantzler (‘20) Cordrea Tankersley (‘17)
S: Sterling Weatherford (’22) Antoine Brooks (‘20) Derwin James (‘18) Derron Smith (‘15) Brock Vereen (‘14)
Special Teams: Rodrigo Blankenship (‘20) Daniel Carlson (‘18)
2008-2019 players were selected by Scott Wright
2020-2021 players were selected by Shane P. Hallam
Follow Shane P. Hallam on twitter @ShanePHallam