Rebuilding an NFL team is a challenge that can take years, with every draft pick carrying weight. Some franchises bank on a star quarterback, hoping for a quick turnaround. Others invest in a dominant defender, building from the trenches. Success isn’t guaranteed either way. Just like in strategy-based games such as AviaMasters, where decisions dictate outcomes, the impact of these choices over the past five drafts offers insight into what truly transforms a struggling team.
2020 Draft: The Burrow Effect vs. Defensive Struggles
Joe Burrow arrived in Cincinnati as the first overall pick, bringing instant hope. A year later, he had the Bengals in the Super Bowl, a feat nearly impossible for a team that had won just two games before his arrival. His leadership, pocket presence, and ability to elevate teammates made a difference.
Chase Young, taken second overall by Washington, had an immediate impact, winning Defensive Rookie of the Year. His dominance was clear, but injuries slowed his progress. While Young strengthened Washington’s defense, the franchise still lacked stability at quarterback, preventing serious playoff contention.
Why Burrow Mattered More
- Team Identity Shift: Cincinnati became a pass-heavy team, built around Burrow’s strengths.
- Playoff Success: A Super Bowl appearance in Year 2 proved his value.
- Leadership: Beyond stats, he changed the culture of a struggling franchise.
Washington’s defense improved with Young, but without a strong quarterback, their ceiling remained low.
2021 Draft: Lawrence’s Growing Pains vs. Parsons’ Instant Dominance
Trevor Lawrence was seen as a generational quarterback talent, but Jacksonville’s issues ran deep. His rookie season was marred by dysfunction, showing how even top-tier quarterback talent can struggle in a chaotic environment. Improvement came in 2022, but Jacksonville remained inconsistent.
Micah Parsons, meanwhile, transformed Dallas’ defense immediately. He won Defensive Rookie of the Year and became a nightmare for offenses. His ability to rush the passer and disrupt plays changed the Cowboys’ defensive identity.
Comparing Their Impacts
- Parsons’ dominance was immediate — he turned Dallas into a top-10 defense.
- Lawrence needed time — quarterbacks rely on system stability, something he lacked early.
- Winning impact — Dallas became a stronger playoff contender faster than Jacksonville.
Parsons’ ability to control games on defense was more immediate than Lawrence’s long-term potential, showing how elite defenders can shift a team’s fortunes faster.
2022 Draft: When Defense Overshadowed the Quarterback
The 2022 draft lacked an elite quarterback prospect, with Malik Willis slipping to the third round. Tennessee took a chance on him, but he failed to earn a starting role. His struggles reinforced the idea that quarterback talent outside the first round is rarely franchise-changing.
Travon Walker, taken first overall by Jacksonville, brought stability to their defensive line. While not yet a game-changer, his presence helped solidify a defense that had been inconsistent.
The Lessons Here
- Rebuilding requires a strong quarterback — teams without one remain stuck.
- Defensive talent offers stability — Jacksonville’s defense improved with Walker, even if he wasn’t dominant.
- A weak QB class slows rebuilds — Tennessee’s gamble on Willis showed the risk of reaching for a non-elite talent.
2023 Draft: The First-Year Test for Young and Anderson
Bryce Young entered the league as Carolina’s top pick, expected to lead their rebuild. But rookie quarterbacks often struggle, and he faced a tough transition. The Panthers lacked offensive weapons, limiting his impact in Year 1.
Will Anderson Jr., taken third by Houston, showcased his pass-rushing ability early. His pressure on quarterbacks helped Houston’s defense become more competitive.
First-Year Impact Breakdown
- Young struggled behind a weak offensive line — Carolina’s lack of support limited his effectiveness.
- Anderson disrupted opposing offenses — his skill set translated faster to the NFL.
- Immediate vs. long-term impact — a dominant defender often makes a difference sooner than a rookie QB learning the system.
2024 Draft: The Expectations for Williams and Verse
Caleb Williams arrived in Chicago with enormous expectations. The Bears, long searching for a franchise quarterback, finally made their move. Whether he succeeds depends on coaching, weapons, and development. Williams already played his rookie season in 2024, showing flashes of potential but also facing challenges typical for a young quarterback.
Jared Verse, a top pass rusher, joined Seattle’s defense. Like Williams, he completed his first NFL season, demonstrating his ability to pressure quarterbacks effectively. If he becomes an elite disruptor, he could have an early impact similar to Parsons or Anderson.
What to Watch
- Williams has pressure to deliver immediately — Chicago expects results fast.
- Verse could elevate Seattle’s defense early — elite pass rushers can dominate from Day 1.
- Quarterbacks take time — if Chicago fails to support Williams, his impact may be delayed.
Final Takeaways: What Rebuilds Faster?
From the past five drafts, elite defenders tend to make an immediate impact. Parsons, Anderson, and Young all improved their teams’ defenses right away. Quarterbacks, however, require time and the right environment. Burrow showed how transformative a great quarterback can be, but he was an outlier. Most, like Lawrence and Young, struggle early.
What Matters More in a Rebuild?
- If a team lacks a quarterback, drafting one is essential — but patience is required.
- A dominant defender can speed up success — elite pass rushers shift games quickly.
- Supporting cast determines QB success — Burrow thrived because Cincinnati built around him.
Teams in rebuild mode must weigh these factors. If a franchise finds its Burrow, the turnaround is massive. But without the right support, even elite quarterback prospects can struggle. Meanwhile, defensive stars provide an instant boost, giving franchises much-needed stability. The right answer? It depends on the team’s current state and long-term vision.

