Despite only making a move to the Cleveland Browns in the 2025 NFL draft, there are rumours quarterback Shedeur Sanders could be on the move. Those rumours suggest that the Indianapolis Colts are the most likely destination for the former Colorado offensive player.
Cleveland Browns’ Super Bowl Chances
The Cleveland Browns are not considered contenders for the next Super Bowl. Sportsbooks have effectively ranked them 30th to lift the Bowl, at odds of +25,000, with bettors able to get improved odds from new US sites as well as by taking advantage of the wealth of bonuses on offer from sportsbooks. According to online betting expert James Briscoe, punters can enjoy a variety of bonuses, including first-deposit matches and more.
Trading Up
The Browns traded up to secure Shedeur Sanders in the draft. They relinquished their 166th and 192nd picks to procure the 144th selection from the Seattle Seahawks, and snapped the player up. On the face of it, and considering their crowded quarterback room, it now seems like an odd decision. It was a surprise that Sanders drafted so low – he was expected to be picked much sooner, which means the Browns did arguably get good value.
General manager Andrew Berry said of the Sanders pick: “Once it got to a point where it felt like it was a pretty steep discount, we just felt like, especially relative to the alternative ways that we could use this selection, this made the most sense.”
Sanders’ Surprise
Some analysts believed Sanders would go on day 1, and virtually all were surprised when he still wasn’t selected on day 2. There have long been rumors about his pre-draft interviews and how poorly he came across, and it is possible that teams thought the distractions he would bring outweighed his talent.
Furthermore, the primary teams that he would have fit had other ideas of where to use their drafts, and by the third day, he had few suitors left. He only represented value as the draft progressed.
The Cleveland Quarterback Room
But Sanders is one of five QBs now at Cleveland, and he looks unlikely to be the first choice, unless he has an exceptional preseason.
Having invested a lot of time in Sanders before the draft, the Browns may have felt compelled to complete his signing. The team’s ownership group travelled to Boulder to court the player and former teammate, Travis Hunter. And they spent a lot of other time with him before the pick.
Cleveland likely wanted to avoid a repeat of the 2022 draft when they sacrificed three first-rounders and a $230m contract to secure Deshaun Watson as quarterback. Three years later, and they are still paying the price for what owner Jimmy Haslam has called “a big swing and miss.”
Watson Out?
Watson is one of five quarterbacks still at the franchise, but an Achilles injury means he is likely to miss the next several months. Joe Flacco and Kenny Pickett were also added during the offseason, and, before they drafted Sanders, the Browns picked up Dillon Gabriel in the third round of this year’s draft.
Watson still has two years left on his five-year contract, and the Browns will have to pay out $92m over those two seasons. It is highly likely they will want some return from that investment, which means, when he is fit, Watson will get at least some opportunity to show his worth.
QB Problems
Since Baker Mayfield left the Browns for the Panthers in 2022, the team has had eight starting quarterbacks, including four in the last season. The Browns are expected to compete next season, which means there’s a lot of pressure on coaches Kevin Strefanski and Andrew Berry to find the best player in what is arguably the most important position on the field.
Sanders Could Be On The Move
Barry is unlikely to want to get rid of Sanders even before the start of the training camp. He may outperform the rest of the QBs, after all. But if he doesn’t perform and it looks like he won’t be pushing for a starting spot, Barry may look to get some kind of value from the fifth-round draft. One way to do that would be a trade. In that regard, the Colts have emerged as a likely target.
The Colts
While the Browns have a quarterback room bursting at the seams, the Indianapolis Colts are somewhat short in that department. They currently have two potential starters.
There are question marks over whether Anthony Richardson is ready to be the number 1 quarterback, which leaves Daniel Jones. That the Colts are being linked with Sanders is somewhat damning for Jones’s potential. For this reason, some believe that general manager Chris Ballard may be ready to roll the dice and take a chance on Sanders.

