The NFL never runs short of surprises, and every season, a new crop of underdogs, rookies, and overlooked veterans rise to fantasy and franchise relevance. While headlines fixate on big-name stars and multimillion-dollar contracts, there’s real value in identifying sleepers—the players poised to exceed expectations and change the trajectory of both fantasy seasons and real-life playoff hopes. These are the names you did not expect—but might just make all the difference in 2025.
Tyjae Spears – RB, Tennessee Titans
With Derrick Henry now in Baltimore, the Titans’ backfield is up for grabs, and Tyjae Spears is the lead candidate to take over. Spears averaged 4.5 yards per carry in limited action in 2024 but saw significant usage increases in Weeks 15 through 18, totaling 295 rushing yards and 3 touchdowns in that span. His ability to catch out of the backfield—38 receptions for 326 yards last year—makes him a dual-threat weapon. At just 23 years old and with no significant injury history, Spears has top 15 RB upside if the Titans stay committed to the run.
Jahan Dotson – WR, Washington Commanders
Jahan Dotson quietly finished 2024 with 63 receptions, 741 yards, and 6 touchdowns, but it is his rapport with rookie QB Jayden Daniels that is generating buzz at training camp. Dotson ran 81% of his routes from the slot last season, and Daniels targeted the slot 31.8% of the time in college. With Curtis Samuel gone and defenses focused on Terry McLaurin, Dotson could easily eclipse 1,000 yards in 2025. His current ADP outside the top 50 receivers makes him an adp fantasy football 2025 bargain.
Luke Musgrave – TE, Green Bay Packers
Jordan Love showed considerable growth in the second half of 2024, and Luke Musgrave benefited, especially in red zone packages. Musgrave logged 5 red zone TDs in the final 6 games, finishing the year with 49 receptions, 512 yards, and 6 touchdowns despite missing 4 games with an abdominal strain. At 6’6″, 253 pounds with 4.61 speed, he is a matchup nightmare. With Romeo Doubs and Christian Watson drawing attention outside, Musgrave could become Love’s top red-zone option in 2025.
Tank Dell – WR, Houston Texans
Tank Dell may no longer be flying completely under the radar, but the fantasy world still underrates his ceiling. Despite missing the final four games of 2024 with a fractured fibula, Dell finished with 61 receptions, 839 yards, and 7 TDs on just 89 targets. His 2.27 yards per route run was in the top 10 among WRs with over 50 targets. C.J. Stroud’s trust in Dell—evidenced by his 27.1% target share in the red zone—makes him a sleeper with WR2 potential.
Zamir White – RB, Las Vegas Raiders
Josh Jacobs is now a Green Bay Packer, and Zamir White is ready to command the Raiders’ backfield. In the final three games of 2024, White racked up 294 rushing yards and 2 touchdowns on 59 carries. That is a 5.0 yards-per-carry average behind a retooled offensive line. His pass-catching skills are limited, with just 12 receptions last year, but if he dominates early down work, his volume will carry him into RB2 territory in standard leagues.
Jaleel McLaughlin – RB, Denver Broncos
Jaleel McLaughlin averaged 5.4 yards per carry and 9.1 yards per reception in 2024, despite receiving just 118 touches all season. With Javonte Williams still recovering from multiple knee surgeries and rookie Audric Estimé expected to be used in short-yardage situations, McLaughlin could see an expanded role. His 22% snap share in 2024 is expected to rise significantly, and Payton has a history of maximizing scatback talent. A 1,000-yard season (combined) is not far-fetched.
Rashid Shaheed – WR, New Orleans Saints
Rashid Shaheed was the NFL’s most efficient deep threat in 2024, averaging 18.3 yards per reception. He turned just 43 receptions into 787 yards and 6 touchdowns. With Chris Olave commanding double coverage and Michael Thomas cut in the offseason, Shaheed should see more targets. His 13.1 aDOT (average depth of target) ranked 4th in the league. If Derek Carr can stay consistent—or if the Saints turn to rookie Spencer Rattler—Shaheed’s speed will be leveraged even more.
Dontayvion Wicks – WR, Green Bay Packers
Dontayvion Wicks became one of Jordan Love’s most reliable third-down targets late in 2024, finishing with 41 receptions for 617 yards and 4 touchdowns. In games where Christian Watson was out, Wicks averaged 6.3 targets and 74.5 yards. His route precision and ability to work the intermediate zones make him a candidate for a bigger workload, especially if Watson continues to struggle with hamstring issues. Expect Wicks to push for WR3 relevance in fantasy lineups.
Michael Mayer – TE, Las Vegas Raiders
Michael Mayer was quiet for most of his rookie season, posting 34 catches for 409 yards and 5 touchdowns. But 4 of those TDs came after Week 10 once Aidan O’Connell took over full-time under center. The Raiders’ new offensive coordinator Alex Van Pelt, formerly of the Browns, loves using tight ends in the red zone—David Njoku had 11 TDs under him in 2022-23 combined. Mayer’s role is set to grow, and his 6’4”, 265-pound frame gives him a major advantage inside the 20.
Keaton Mitchell – RB, Baltimore Ravens
Keaton Mitchell is back from a torn ACL, and while Derrick Henry is the RB1 in Baltimore, the 33-year-old veteran is unlikely to handle a 90% snap share. Mitchell’s 8.4 yards per touch in 2024—on 47 touches—was the highest among RBs with at least 30 touches. Lamar Jackson’s ability to pull defenders with read options opens lanes for Mitchell, who could be deployed heavily on third downs and outside runs. If Henry misses any time, Mitchell becomes an instant top-15 RB.
Do not Sleep on the Sleepers
While stars carry headlines, leagues are won in the trenches of your draft later rounds. Players like Tyjae Spears, Tank Dell, and Michael Mayer may not appear in the top 30 picks, but they have the skill sets, opportunity, and rising usage rates to produce elite-level returns. Building your bench with these upside-down plays can make or break a fantasy season. Keep your eyes sharp, and your picks sharper.

